Bye-bye, Christian Slater. His NBC actioner My Own Worst Enemy has just become the latest film star showcase to get axed fast.
Slater isn't alone, that's for sure. More movie stars than we can count have fumbled trying to play the TV series game.
What's the deal? Doesn't big-screen charisma translate to the home screen? Do feature names lord their fame over those who know TV better? Or are producers ineffective working bass-ackwards to shape shows around star personas?
The cocky appeal Slater had strutted for two decades since Heathers was pretty much submerged in an NBC set-up so complicated, his show became its own worst enemy. Producers could barely describe their double-life subliminally switched-on secret- agent story when they hyped it at last summer's press tour. Thus baffled critics couldn't tout the tale to readers. And few viewers wended their way through the story's machinations.
But complication isn't always the case.
Look at Sally Field. Sure, the spunky actress is winning friends and Emmys now on ABC's Brothers & Sisters. But when the same network designed a fairly clear-cut show around Field in 2002 -- The Court, where she wrangled with other decision-delivering Supremes -- the result was three-weeks-and-out. Field's current Sunday night success says her hard-driving persona works better as part of a wide-ranging ensemble, and in a family setting, rather than a workplace/issues framework.
Other crowdpleasers who seemed like sure bets to soar on TV have taken nose dives instead. When flashy-fun Bette Midler headlined CBS' half- hour Bette by essentially playing herself -- a movie star trying to lead a normal life with her husband and teenage daughter -- industry observers marked it fall 2000's surest hit. But the show got mucked-with post-pilot in recasts of the husband and daughter. Samantha Who? dad Kevin Dunn gave way to Airplane!-er Robert Hays, while hot Parent Trap teen Lindsay Lohan (!) was replaced by Marina (who?) Malota. Choices like that made the show safer. And duller. Even with a parade of glitzy guests -- Oprah Winfrey, Tim Curry, Dolly Parton -- Bette didn't last a season.
Neither did the hot pick of 2003, NBC's Miss Match, starring Alicia Silverstone as a matchmaker in a sort of land-locked love boat. The Clueless star showed charm to burn, but the Friday night hour crashed. Maybe scheduling its lighthearted romance on a date night wasn't such a hot idea. And its makers seemed clueless how to showcase their star's appeal amid new situations weekly.
Whoops with Whoopi, too. This 2003 NBC sitcom cast Whoopi Goldberg as an ex-R&B star running a quirky Manhattan inn peopled by offbeat characters -- her political-opposite conservative brother, his black-talking white girlfriend, a Persian janitor. Great setup for Comedy Central, maybe, or Showtime. But the show's hard-edged topicality and opinion-spouting characters were not exactly network- audience friendly.
Drama series have also been duds for movie stars trying TV. Richard Dreyfuss played a college professor -- another long-shot setting -- in CBS' 2001 drama The Education of Max Bickford, which also featured a transgendered character played by Helen Shaver. Not a good bet in Sunday's old Murder She Wrote timeslot. (Although the show did offer Battlestar Galactica star-to-be Katee Sackhoff as Dreyfuss' daughter.)
Karen Sisco marked a much ballyhooed TV return for Carla Gugino, the ex-Spin City second banana who found big-screen fame playing mom in the Spy Kids flicks. ABC's 2003 actioner, based on the Jennifer Lopez movie Out of Sight, debuted with high expectations. But barely made it a month.
And these are just the recent no-gos. You could glance back to the early '70s for just one flurry of flops from such certified filmland legends as James Stewart (the familycom The Jimmy Stewart Show, legal eagle in Hawkins), Henry Fonda (The Smith Family), Debbie Reynolds (The Debbie Reynolds Show) and Shirley MacLaine (Shirley's World).
But let's look forward. Who'll be the next big-screener bellyflopping into the tube pool? We could throw around such dwindling-draw names as Julia Roberts, Kevin Costner, even Madonna, who's now 50 and can't sex it up on arena stages forever. Eddie Murphy and Robin Williams started in TV, remember, and could well end up returning.
In the meantime, if Brothers & Sisters needs to fill any more secret-surprise relative roles, we hear Christian Slater's available.
Sponsored Links
39 Comments
Add a comment
MOST RECENT POSTS
Today's TWoP News: Thursday, April 17, 2012
The CW Upfront 2012: Recycling All The Pretty People
Modern Family: Best Lines of the Night
Fall TV 2012: What's On When
Thursday, May 17, 2012: Grey's Anatomy
CBS Upfront 2012: Now With Even More Cops, Lawyers and Vegas
Today's TWoP News: Wednesday, May 16, 2012
TNT and TBS Upfront 2012: Boldly Going Where Other Networks Already Went
BLOG ARCHIVES
Brilliant But Cancelled
May 2012
1 Entries
April 2012
2 Entries
March 2012
1 Entries
February 2012
1 Entries
January 2012
1 Entries
November 2011
2 Entries
October 2011
3 Entries
September 2011
2 Entries
August 2011
3 Entries
July 2011
2 Entries
June 2011
2 Entries
April 2011
4 Entries
March 2011
3 Entries
February 2011
2 Entries
January 2011
2 Entries
November 2010
1 Entries
October 2010
2 Entries
September 2010
2 Entries
July 2010
3 Entries
June 2010
2 Entries
May 2010
1 Entries
April 2010
3 Entries
March 2010
6 Entries
February 2010
2 Entries
January 2010
3 Entries
December 2009
1 Entries
November 2009
2 Entries
October 2009
2 Entries
September 2009
2 Entries
August 2009
5 Entries
July 2009
8 Entries
June 2009
5 Entries
May 2009
3 Entries
April 2009
2 Entries
March 2009
3 Entries
February 2009
2 Entries
January 2009
5 Entries
December 2008
2 Entries
November 2008
3 Entries
October 2008
4 Entries
September 2008
6 Entries
July 2008
5 Entries
June 2008
2 Entries
May 2008
7 Entries
April 2008
9 Entries
March 2008
1 Entries
February 2008
2 Entries
November 2007
1 Entries
Fascinating topic. I love "My Own Worst Enemy" and will mourn it. I wondered if there were any examples of stars that did successfully make the jump.
I can think of:
Keifer Sutherland -- A-lister in the early 90s, but had faded by the time "24" came along. Could Kevin Bacon be next?
Rob Lowe -- Like Sally Field, probably helped by the ensemble in West Wing and Brother & Sisters.
Alec Baldwin -- Another fading guy who now has a hit. (Perhaps Kim Basinger could be next)
Oddly enough, two of the ones mentioned above still had movie careers, albeit in ensembles casts. A;ec Baldwin was incredible in the Cooler. Kevin Bacon was fantastic in Mystic River.
I think the next Hollywood flops won't be fading movie stars, as much as we'll begin to see celebutantes trying to act... Nicole Ritchie, Kimberly Stewart, etc... And those shows will fail!
I like Christian Slater but was completely bored by the show.
Other movie stars successfully moving to TV ...
Charlie Sheen
Lucille Ball
Fred McMurray
Stupid NBC. Ican't see more than one season out of this show before it becomes as tedious as Lost, but I could see one season of solid, interesting storytelling.
Now what? Yet another night of Deal or No Deal?
Note to people developing interesting shows that require a little thought from the audience: if you don't get picked up by ABC don't bother with broadcast networks. Remember Firefly, Briscoe County Jr, Journeyman, and now My Own Worst Enemy.
In regards to this article, I found only one thing I truly disagree. The notion that Whoopi Goldberg is a star. Just...No. No on talent, no on fame, just simply, NO.
"Bette" was one of four heavily hyped shows starring big names that came out that season. The other three shows were "The Geena Davis Show", "The Michael Richards Show", and "Normal, Ohio" starring John Goodman. Although Richards and Goodman are mostly known from their former TV characters, they did attempt to foray into movies (Trial and Error, The Flintstones). All four of those shows combimed to produce a total of 18 episodes of bleh!
Stars don't always crash; if you're going back to the '70s, James Garner clicked pretty well in The Rockford Files and made one of TV's classic detective shows. Candice Bergen, a movie star of sorts, I suppose, had a good long run with Murphy Brown. Cybill Sherpherd in Moonlighting, too.
Damn - it was complicated but I was enjoying this show :(
Gary Sinise! Loved him in Forrest Gump. Doing not too bad in CSI NY (if you're into the show).
I knew this show was not going to work. Besides, the original British version was much better. It was a show called Jekyll and Hyde. One man with two lives. Jekyll, a husband and father the other, Hyde, a cold blooded killer and they were totally oblivious to the details of each other's lives. Oh...and the assistant to Jekyll/Hyde was no other than the woman who played Jamie Summers in NBC's botched revival of the Bionic Woman last season.
I Love MOWE!!!! I think it is wonderful, and I think the "machinations" are wonderfully contrived...and I think 5 million viewers a week agree with me...
I like all the characters, and I can't wait to see what happens each week, and Christian Slater does a fabulous job of making Henry Henry, and Edward Edward.
I don't understand...I will miss this show horribly, and I keep thinking should I start a petition?
I agree! Except I could see more than one season....but yeah, Lost has become tedious...I stopped watching in Season Three or Four....
But Word! to Journeyman, and Firefly.....
My gut feeling from the premise of MOWE was that it was destined for cancellation. The idea could be milked for at most one season. I caught it one night when I was bored and I thought Christian Slater did an excellent job portraying Henry and Edward. He also looked like he was having a lot of fun. :)
I hope he gets another TV show soon! I would watch anything he is in!
I agree I LOVE the show. I just think it's on too late. Needs to be on at the 8 or 9pm slot. possibly different night? He's a GREAT actor and deserves another chance!!!
Were you not around in the 80's and 90's? There were plenty of Whoopi Goldberg movies out then.
The Color Purple
Sister Act
Corrina, Corrina
Clara's Heart
Jumpin' Jack Flash
Ghost
The Lion King
Star Trek : Generations
Girl Interrupted
I could go on. She is most definitely a star.
One would have thought that having Slater in the lead on this show would have enticed a larger audience to sample it. But, after those who adore the CSI cast and everyone else watching the Football game; not many were left to find MOWE. Too bad! It's really quite entertaining, particularly with Christian Slater doing such a magnificent job portraying two unique characters who are supposed to remain separate but communicate with each other to save each other from behaving inappropriately. What great fun!
I'll surely miss this adventure. The Show's interactive element was great fun too. Giving their audience the opportunity to apply for a job as a spy, get hired, issued a credential, password and secret documents for background and spoiler fun to try.
Too bad about MOWE. It was just starting to get interesting.
I'm surprised you didn't mention Jeff Goldblum's recent attempt at TV in "Raines". Or as I like to call it "What if the Kid from the 'Sixth Sense' Grew up, still saw dead people, used said dead head's knowledge to solve crimes and looked like Jeff Goldblum".
Unfortunately, you can also add Eli Stone to this list. ABC said this week it is not ordering any more episodes after its 13 that already in the can at the moment. Depressing really... its one of the best TV shows on at the moment, and the only one I watch live. The star - Johnny Lee Miller is most recognizable for his role in Hackers as Dade Murphy, and Mindhunters as Lucas Harper.
I love this show!! I got it! Maybe they should've moved it to a Friday time slot before they cancelled it. It really was a good show
Lets not forget Charlie Sheen, now on the 6th season of "Two and a Half Men" (one of my favorite shows). That's just the one that leaped out at me, I'm sure I could think of more.
Petitions never work. The only canceled show that I can recall being brought back was "Family Guy", and I suspect that had more to do with the DVD sales going through the roof, and they realized that there was a lot more money to be made off the show than they thought. Always comes down to money, doesn't it?
I say they put this show on USA! They have several crime shows on there, and I really loved Christian Slater in this role! It was genius, plus Raymond, loved his 2 personalities--I never understand why they keep so many bad shows on regular TV, most of the good shows are on cable nowadays! Let's go to USA!
A
Call it the "Lost Effect". If any show starts looking overly complicated, "BAM", replace it with cheap (comparatively) reality shows or gameshows. Too bad intelligent television is so hard to keep around.
Call it the "Lost Effect". If any show starts looking overly complicated, "BAM", replace it with cheap (comparatively) reality shows or gameshows. Too bad intelligent television is so hard to keep around.
I totally agree! I love this show and so does my husband. It was finally a show that was entertaining for the mind and kept you on your toes. Let me know if a petition starts..I'll sign it!
The premise was stupid, he was 2 people or something, he should come back in something else. He's an excellent actor, but the plot was hard to follow and it was stupid.
Sad to see the show go but Christian is a Great actor and I hope he can land something soon
I love MOWE! I can't believe they are keeping Knight rider and canceling this show. What a joke. I hope another network comes in and saves it like ABC did with "Scrubs". If this is too intelligent for the American people, that doesn't say much for the rest of the viewers, does it? But it could explain why Rush Limbaugh and Jerry Springer are so popular.
I love MOWE! I can't believe they are keeping Knight rider and canceling this show. What a joke. I hope another network comes in and saves it like ABC did with "Scrubs". If this is too intelligent for the American people, that doesn't say much for the rest of the viewers, does it? But it could explain why Rush Limbaugh and Jerry Springer are so popular.
Word of advice, don't watch ANYTHING on NBC, they don't know what good is. They move stuff around too much, losing viewers or they cancel the good shows like MOWE. What happened to Friday Night Lights? Risky showing it on Direct Tv first. I'll be back, but what about others who in invest in other shows during the hiatus? I really hate to invest any time in this network.....they should become a game show network - that's about all they chose to hang on to.
I agree! I love this show! Finally, a smart, exciting drama that thinks outside the normal detective show box. I am so sad to see MOWE go! I'll sign your petition! Who do we bombard with our emails???
This show was a little violent for the general public but was a good one. Lets just keep putting on more reality shows. They are cheap and make lots of money for you know who. Perfect for the easily led masses...reality....give me a break...call them what they really are...rehearsal shows that dupe the public into what they perceive as reality.
This show was setup to fail from the start the time slot was 10pm on a Monday night yeah that would work well.
Let's face it: anything requiring an audience with an attention span of more than 30 seconds and an IQ of more than 80 is doomed to fail. Unless it is on cable. If you want idiotic and demeaning reality shows and stupid,mind numbing dance competitions,go ahead and watch network television. If you want anything that isn't totally geared toward idiots head to cable--HBO,AMC,FX,Showtime. That's where the good stuff is.
My Own Worst Enemy shouldn't have been canceled in my opinion. It's a lot better than many of the cop shows that have enjoyed numerous seasons and spins off. I prefer My Own Worst Enemy it over a lot of the mindless shows that we see picked up year after year. I'm hoping another network will be smart enough to pick up My Own Worst Enemy, Eli Stone, Pushing Daisies, Journeyman, Canterbury's Law, and The Women's Murder Club. All of which were interesting and well written. The networks really need to stop dumbing down television. My Own Worst Enemy was not complicated to follow. It's less complicated than Heroes and Terminator: The Sarah Conner Chronicles, which are also my favorites
too bad, I liked the show but only discovered it mid-season. They should give shows more time! Perhaps if they'd found a shorter name for it.
This show was really awesome! I thought Christian Slater did a fantastic job playing two roles!! I don't know why it was cancelled. I think it was the time slot or more likely the night it was on. Other shows already had a steady following. So Christian's show didn't have the chance of even being veiwed. Bummer
i SO miss MOWE, and the Journeyman...