Bea Arthur: Ahead of Her Time, and Ours

by Rebecca Bellotto April 27, 2009 3:35 PM
Bea Arthur: Ahead of Her Time, and Ours

This weekend we mourned the passing of Bea Arthur, one of the greatest comediennes ever to grace the small screen. She began her acting career as a stage actress, but became a household name in 1972 with the debut of her sitcom Maude on CBS. Her iconic roles as the outspoken liberal feminist Maude Findlay and the equally caustic Dorothy Zbornak on The Golden Girls will be forever beloved, not only because of Arthur's flawless comic timing but also because both women were ahead of their time -- and in some ways, ahead of our time too.

As a spinoff of All in the Family, Maude rocketed into uncharted sitcom territory by taking sharp aim at topics previously untouched on television series, like alcoholism, menopause, suicide, and domestic violence. Bea Arthur deserves unmeasurable credit for portraying a character whose attitudes were considered so outrageous that many television stations refused to air Maude at various points during the show's run. The series ushered in an era of "topical sitcoms" that broke down barriers for what was deemed "acceptable content" on American television.

But some of the walls annihilated by Maude seem to have been built back up by later TV shows. Back in 1972, in the very first season of the series, Maude became pregnant at 47 and after two episodes of struggling, decided to get an abortion. On current television, characters on Everwood, Six Feet Under, and Third Watch have gone through with it, but the vast majority of female characters with unwanted pregnancies end up changing their minds and keeping the baby (as with Miranda on Sex and the City) or suffering a miscarriage that takes the decision out of their hands (as with Cristina on Grey's Anatomy). Some characters who opt for an abortion are even punished, as on 2004's Jack and Bobby when the character Missy was killed in a car crash just one episode after undergoing an abortion. How have attitudes towards the depiction of a woman's right to choose on television regressed so much in the 37 years since Maude's dilemma?

And though it might not seem as obvious, lessons learned from The Golden Girls have also fallen by the wayside in the years since the show went off the air. Dorthy Zbornak was just as sharp-tongued as Arthur's previous incarnation Maude, and the show dealt with issues like gay marriage, transsexualism, and even HIV in the same comic but thought-provoking way. But The Golden Girls also brought to the small screen a topic that in recent years has devolved to little more than a punchline: the elderly. Dorothy, Sophia, Blanche, and Rose had active lives and loved sex just as much as any twenty-something Real World recruit of recent years. But when older characters have appeared on recent sitcoms -- which they do less and less frequently -- their actions are played strictly for laughs, as with Frank and Marie on Everybody Loves Raymond, Cotton on King of the Hill, or Grampa on The Simpsons. How is it that the non-elderly-friendly activities of older people have become a running joke since The Golden Girls ended?

Things haven't changed as much as one might have hoped since Maude was a top-ten series. Were some controversial episodes from Maude and The Golden Girls to air in primetime today, they would probably receive as much or more protest as they did decades ago -- assuming that a show about an outspoken middle-aged feminist or four older women was even allowed to go on the air. Bea Arthur used her untouchable comic prowess to help pioneer television that allowed characters to deal with touchy issues in a natural way, without preaching, making fun, or labeling one side "wrong." Let's not allow that door, which she worked so hard to open, to swing shut.

6 Comments

April 27, 2009 4:36 PM
Caitlin
Reply

What a beautiful and timely tribute!

April 27, 2009 4:43 PM
Tatum
Reply

She will be missed, but I don't think the proverbial door her brand of comedy helped open is in danger of being shut. As for the references to the abortion issue, surely there are people in the world who decide NOT to abort unwanted children or have miscarriages. I think it would be unrealistic to portray every "mistake" of a pregnancy as ending in abortion.

My two cents! :)

April 27, 2009 7:01 PM
Kyle
Reply

It is just so sad, especially now that two of the four Golden Girls are gone. However, it is pretty amazing to see all of the well-spoken word I have been reading about Bea Arthur. Betty White and Rue Mcclanahan were on the Today Show this morning and it was really great to hear the two women remember such a great actress. If you missed it on the show, you can watch it on the Today Show iPhone app: http://itunes.apple.com/WebObjects/MZStore.woa/wa/viewSoftware?id=309546027&mt=8

April 29, 2009 6:40 AM
Marissa
Reply

My grandfather, a Michigan conservative Republican, blue-color worker, who listened to Rush Limbaugh everyday when he was one the radio, also watched Golden Girls religiously, described Bea Arthur as his favorite person on television, and sent his two daughters to professional school. Are these facts related, no idea, but I can't help but thinking that she might have opened my Grandpa's eyes a little about what a woman can be or do. We'll all miss her.

May 6, 2009 11:53 PM
Connie
Reply

I have loved Bea Arthur since she was Maude on All in the Family, It broke my heart to hear that she had passed. I always wanted to go see her one woman show that she had been doing since retiring from G.G. It is sad that she and Estelle are gone. I am also amazed that her illness had not hit the tabloids, cudos to her family and friends for keeping her sad times from public specticle. I loved her and want to remember her as the great snarky comedian that she was. I do not know what Rue is doing, but I love Betty White on The Bold and the Beautiful, and wish both those women a long long happy golden life, and will continue to watch the GG and remember Bea and Estelle fondly for their great tallent, and for sharing it with the world. I do hope that neither suffered and are in comedy corner in heaven entertaining the saints.

June 21, 2009 7:11 PM
Liz
Reply

I read somewhere where college girls are glued to the GG shows, that these women have become surrogate grandmothers. They could certainly have chosen worse. I watch reruns. Great rapport between the actresses and wonderful writing.

TWoP Toolbar

BLOG ARCHIVES

Brilliant But Cancelled

January 2012

1 Entries

November 2011

2 Entries

October 2011

3 Entries

September 2011

2 Entries

August 2011

3 Entries

July 2011

2 Entries

June 2011

2 Entries

April 2011

4 Entries

March 2011

3 Entries

February 2011

2 Entries

January 2011

2 Entries

November 2010

1 Entries

October 2010

2 Entries

September 2010

2 Entries

July 2010

3 Entries

June 2010

2 Entries

May 2010

1 Entries

April 2010

3 Entries

March 2010

6 Entries

February 2010

2 Entries

January 2010

3 Entries

December 2009

1 Entries

November 2009

2 Entries

October 2009

2 Entries

September 2009

2 Entries

August 2009

5 Entries

July 2009

8 Entries

June 2009

5 Entries

May 2009

3 Entries

April 2009

2 Entries

March 2009

3 Entries

February 2009

2 Entries

January 2009

5 Entries

December 2008

2 Entries

November 2008

3 Entries

October 2008

4 Entries

September 2008

6 Entries

July 2008

5 Entries

June 2008

2 Entries

May 2008

7 Entries

April 2008

9 Entries

March 2008

1 Entries

February 2008

2 Entries

November 2007

1 Entries