@ShitMyDadSays: The TV Series? Been There, Done That

As frequent Twitterers, we're big fans of @ShitMyDadSays, where a man who lives with his parents turns all of his father's withering comments and insults into Tweets. (Example: "Son, no one gives a shit about all the things your cell phone does. You didn't invent it, you just bought it. Anybody can do that.") So when we heard that he was getting a book deal, we were happy for him. Then, when we heard it was becoming a show on CBS, we had to scratch our heads. First of all, the swear words he uses (including the one in the frickin' title) are part of what makes it so funny, and second... it's a show about a grumpy old guy who berates his live-in adult son? How is that different from half the shows on television? We looked back at some of our favorite abusive TV dads from brilliant but cancelled shows.

Red Forman (That '70s Show)
Kurtwood Smith is the quintessential verbally abusive dad, although he often eschewed subtlety in favor of insulting nicknames.
Example: "So, this is how an engaged high-school dumbass with no car, no job and no money trims the hedges."

Al Bundy (Married with Children)
While Eric Forman didn't always deserve the insults his dad leveled at him, Al (Ed O'Neill) called it like he saw it, pointing out Kelly and Bud's failings as children as well as human beings.
Example: "Bud, if you need money, you should do what a wise man once said, "Yip-ip-ip-ip-ip, mu-mu-mu-mu-mu-mu-mu get a job."

Arthur Spooner (King of Queens)
Technically Doug's father-in-law, Arthur still lived with him, and he was played by Jerry Stiller, which meant Doug was regularly mocked for his weight and stupidity.
Example: "You know, we're quite a team. Like Jake and the Fatman. Needless to say, I'm Jake."

Frank Costanza (Seinfeld)
While Jerry's father was usually fairly complimentary (even if they were back-handed compliments), Jerry Stiller was there to be mean enough for both of them as George Costanza's perpetually disappointed dad, whether George was living at home or elsewhere.
Example: "My George isn't clever enough to hatch a scheme like this."

Martin Crane (Frasier)
As the ex-cop father of two staggeringly pretentious psychiatrists, John Mahoney's Martin had plenty of material to work with.
Example: "Try playing the role of a sane person."

Ken Titus (Titus)
He didn't live with his two sons, but the elder Titus (Stacey Keach) caused them enough psychological damage when they were kids to last them well into adulthood.
Example: "You're late! This car's a piece of crap. Where did you get it anyways? It looks like an old man's car! I'll be inside. And park it around back!"

Frank Barone (Everybody Loves Raymond)
Whenever he would stop by to visit, Frank (Peter Boyle) had plenty to say about his sons and his wife.
Example: "I could have eaten a box of Alpha-Bits and crapped a better interview!"

Alan Eppes (Numb3rs)
This show isn't cancelled (yet, anyway), but you can't deny it's got some brilliant (brain-wise) characters in it. Played by Judd Hirsch, chess-loving Alan is proud of his scientist and FBI agent sons, and even lives with one of them, although he is also fond of pointing out how clueless both of them can be about important things like sports and romance.
Example: "That was better. You almost hit the ball."

Who's your favorite insulting TV dad, past or present? Tell us off below, then go to your room.

7 Comments

November 11, 2009 4:06 PM
MaggiSaar
Reply

Here's my question...has the barely begun show based on @shitmydadsays already jumped the shark? Just because of how it was created, how they have to cut out the swearing, and it is pretty much going to be like all the shows you just listed?

Is it possible for a show that hasn't even been written to jump the shark?

November 11, 2009 4:53 PM
Foxed
Reply

Ed O'Neill still has a job (please?)!

... And Kurtwood Smith can go more dramatic for Mean Dad. Dead Poets Society, anyone?

November 11, 2009 5:01 PM
Kat
Reply

When I saw this was going to be a show, I said "just like 'All in the Family'".

November 11, 2009 5:49 PM
Ken
Reply

I'm pretty sure you just laid out why shitmydadsays is perfect for TV. It's an updated version of something TV has done for decades w/ great success and will keep doing. Some of the funniest tweets don't even have swearing in them. If you think it can't be compelling without the bad words then you don't really understand why nearly 800K follow the account.

November 12, 2009 6:57 PM
Brian
Reply

"That woman was sexy...Out of your league? Son. Let women figure out why they won't screw you, don't do it for them."

No swearing and I'd like to see the dalai lama come up with that shit. Brilliant! This has potential to be another great TV series.

December 1, 2009 1:52 AM
JonGreen
Reply

What about the most obvious example of this show already being done--and well- Sanford & Son

January 13, 2010 5:19 PM
evan
Reply

So true. Although I am very curious to see how this show turns out. I would actually like to do some auditions and casting calls for shows like these.

BLOG ARCHIVES

Brilliant But Cancelled

February 2010

1 Entries

January 2010

3 Entries

December 2009

1 Entries

November 2009

2 Entries

October 2009

2 Entries

September 2009

2 Entries

August 2009

5 Entries

July 2009

8 Entries

June 2009

5 Entries

May 2009

3 Entries

April 2009

2 Entries

March 2009

3 Entries

February 2009

2 Entries

January 2009

5 Entries

December 2008

2 Entries

November 2008

3 Entries

October 2008

4 Entries

September 2008

6 Entries

July 2008

5 Entries

June 2008

2 Entries

May 2008

7 Entries

April 2008

9 Entries

March 2008

1 Entries

February 2008

2 Entries

November 2007

1 Entries

Blog Categories

Add category

0 Entries

Deathwatch

5 Entries

Gone Too Soon

4 Entries

Network Baby Steps

1 Entries

Smart TV on DVD

22 Entries

TRENDWATCH

5 Entries

TV Lover

15 Entries

We Knew Them When

23 Entries