Sloane is no stranger to playing sidekicks and outcasts. In the first few seasons of Sabrina, the Teenage Witch, she was Sabrina's slightly geeky friend and admirer. Since then, she's been playing mostly guest roles in failed TV shows, like the Alicia Silverstone vehicle Miss Match, or starring in the blessedly short-lived The Stones. This time she'll be playing a religious "high school teacher" who, instead of winding up at a Bible study, accidentally finds herself at the orgy. (It's a very common mistake, according to any number of fallen televangelists.) Sloane has been on the verge of a breakout for a while, it seems, and it might be nice to see someone who's played her share of "losers" make that transition to big movie stardom. If Jonah Hill can be a leading man, why not?

Orgy also stars Saturday Night Live regulars Will Forte and Jason Sudeikis, although it will thankfully not be an SNL skit-based adaptation.