BLOGS

Why Ten Oscars are Better Than Five (Plus Five Other Oscar Fixes)

America, or at least the Americans who cover the film industry, were stunned by the out-of-the-blue announcement that the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences would be expanding the number of Best Picture nominees next year, from five to ten. The last time there were ten Best Picture nominees was 1943; apparently, winning the war gave Americans less desire to praise movies? Anyway, some people are crying foul, saying that crummy movies will now get nominated, and that's just dumb. We think this is a great idea, and we've got five reasons why in the last five years' worth of great films that didn't make the cut. Of course, in honor of the we also have a list of five other things that the Oscars still need to fix.

Reason #1: 2008
Last year was a big year for snubbed movies. Not only was The Wrestler just begging for a nod, but the superhero genre saw two of its greatest movies ever, The Dark Knight and Iron Man, and neither stood a chance in the biased world of the Academy. Maybe a ten-nominee field would have gotten one of them to the big dance? Definitely on that ten-figure list would have been WALL-E, which everyone was calling the Best Picture of the year long before it won Best Animated Feature.

Reason #2: 2007
Another big year, 2007 brought us Gone Baby Gone, Into the Wild and Eastern Promises, and while you can argue whether Juno deserved its nomination, you can't argue that these three didn't deserve a shot as well.

Reason #3: 2006
Epic, pulse-pounding and technically superb, Children of Men was science fiction so visceral and familiar that it almost made us forget that we weren't living in a sterile society on the brink of collapse. If it'd been a documentary, it would have won hands down, but thank God it wasn't.

Reason #4: 2005
The Constant Gardener. Ralph Fiennes. Rachel Weisz. Bill Nighy. Africa. Drug testing. Murder. Fractured narrative. How did this not get nominated again?

Reason #5: 2004
Michel Gondry's directorial masterpiece and Charlie Kaufman's most mind-bending script yet, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind gave us Kate Winslet at her crazed best and Jim Carrey at his most subdued, and the supporting cast (Dunst, Ruffalo, Wood, Wilkinson and Cross) filled the corners of this time-jumping sci-fi dramedy with pure win.

And that's just the last five years! However, while a more varied Best Picture race would mean a more exciting broadcast, there are still things the Academy needs to fix to make the Oscar race, and the ceremony itself, more interesting:

1. Even more nominees.
It's not just the Best Picture race. All of the categories are skewed towards dramatic, non-genre performances; only rarely does a comedic role like Johnny Depp's sublime Jack Sparrow or Robert Downey Jr.'s daring blackface turn break through. Expanding the main acting categories as well would give a lot more comedic and genre roles a chance.

2. Allow early nomination.
Early-in-the-year movies are completely handicapped against getting nominated, since voters have forgotten about them by the new year, which is why November and December are always jam-packed with prestige films. And we're sorry, but the holiday season is no time for the theaters to be full of Nazi flicks. The Academy should announce a July nomination round, so studios can start spreading out their quality films.

3. Less government interference.
The films in the Best Foreign Film category are still chosen and submitted by the governments of their respective countries. That seems a little weird, right? Like, if the Oscars were held somewhere else, what movie would the U.S. government choose to submit? Doesn't seem like such a good idea now, does it?

4. Make voters go to the movies.
It used to be that the Academy held screenings of nominated films for its members, but because the films are all sent out on DVD now, there's no way of knowing whether the people voting are even watching them. Or they may be making a sandwich or reading a book while the thing is playing. Mandatory theatrical screenings would restrict the voting to people who had definitely seen the films, and it would present the films in the format for which they were intended.

5. Get them drunk.
The worst part of the Oscars? No drinking at the ceremony. The Golden Globes are a lot more fun, with swearing and bird-flipping aplenty. Get those celebrities hammered!

What do you think of the proposed changes to the nomination round?

8 Comments

June 27, 2009 8:44 AM
Brian of the North
Reply

"Like, if the Oscars were held somewhere else, what movie would the U.S. government choose to submit?"

That's kind of what Cannes is isn't it?

June 27, 2009 9:46 AM
Abigail
Reply

I can't speak for all countries, but there's no government involvement in the selection of Israel's best foreign picture nominee. The nominee is the film voted best film of the year by the members of the Israeli academy of film. As far as I know, it's always the national filmmakers' association that's responsible for submitting the best foreign picture nominee, which is selected either through a popular vote or by a committee, but that's not the same thing as a governmental body. Similarly, to the commenter above me - the Cannes film festival is not an official body of the government of France, and its jury, whose members are often not French citizens, most certainly isn't.

Your examples of films that ought to have made it onto the best picture ballot don't make for a very persuasive argument for expanding the number of nominees because you've left out the fact that the films that did get nominated usually didn't deserve to. The problem isn't the number of good films in a year - it's that fact that the Academy consistently fails to recognize them and instead chooses to award safe and uninteresting pap.

June 27, 2009 2:42 PM
Zelmia
Reply

I don't think either "Gone, Baby, Gone" or "Into the Wild" deserved to be nominated for anything. While both films were based on reasonably interesting concepts, the execution was completely lackluster on both counts. I'm not sure I even agree that "Eastern Promises" deserved any nominations other than what it actually got: recognition for Viggo Mortensen's complete disappearance into the character of Nikolai.

I agree with Abigail that increasing the number of nominees isn't likely to encourage the Academy voters to step away from the "Oscar bait". There will just be more of it to go around.

June 27, 2009 3:07 PM
JohnnyB
Reply

I think your article points out exactly why Oscars should only have 5 nominations for best pic. You list a bunch of movies, the only one of which that deserved to be nominated was the Wrestler (over the Reader). Dark Knight and Iron Man didnt belong anywhere near Best Picture contention, unless its the SciFi FanBoy Show (IE MTV Awards).

Whats worse(!) is that with 10 nominations, the winning film only has to get 11% of the vote to win. That is hardly an overwhelming victory. The extra nominees will divide the votes even more, and I fear it will be the independent (The Wrestler-type) films that end up getting the shaft.

They may get the recognition of a nomination... but what is it worth when there are TEN films each year. At least when a good independent film gets the nomination (out of five), it can really feel like vindication -- plus, the film (or actor) often stands a better chance for surprise victory.

June 29, 2009 7:03 PM
F. Booth
Reply

I absolutely LOVED Tokyo! I thought all three parts were surreal yet humane and quite compelling.

You can order the dvd on the official website: http://bit.ly/TokyoTheMovie
6/29/09 6:52 PM

July 2, 2009 2:11 PM
Kel Varnsen
Reply

I don't see how it will help, at most you listed 2 or 3 movies that got snubbed. So those movies get nominated along with 3 other crappy oscar bait movies that also won't win. You add that to the vote splitting that JohnnyB mentioned and the result is going to be the safe/obvious front runner winning every time.

July 6, 2009 6:07 PM
growltiger
Reply

You know, there is a reason why genre films do not get the nod. What makes you think expanding the slot count will enable recognition for good horror, science fiction, animation, or what have you? Independent films have done well as of late. Expanding the slot count just enables box office winners to re-assert themselves.

And the specter of 600 votes (more or less 11% of the eligible electorate) being the winner's tally should force the academy to think through this idea.

July 6, 2009 7:44 PM
SixDog
Reply

Instead of 10 films, I think the academy should go the way of having different categories for films, They could have 5 nominees in Drama and 5 nominees in Comedy/Action films. Otherwise, the academy is still going to pick the so-called intellectual films that very few people want to see, including the Academy members. They can pat themselves on the back for being so high class and above it all but they're really just turning their back on the films that most of us want to see.

Loading...

Add a comment

BLOG ARCHIVES

The Moviefile

November 2009

17 Entries

October 2009

27 Entries

September 2009

30 Entries

August 2009

28 Entries

July 2009

34 Entries

June 2009

27 Entries

May 2009

24 Entries

April 2009

23 Entries

March 2009

18 Entries

February 2009

30 Entries

January 2009

56 Entries

December 2008

51 Entries

November 2008

61 Entries

October 2008

102 Entries

September 2008

86 Entries

August 2008

99 Entries

July 2008

116 Entries

June 2008

95 Entries

May 2008

86 Entries

April 2008

67 Entries

March 2008

14 Entries

Blog Categories

Accidents Do Happen

42 Entries

Box Office Tally

55 Entries

Coming Soonish

7 Entries

Cool Nerds Guide

2 Entries

DVDs Unwrapped

22 Entries

Foreign Relations

31 Entries

Girls on Film

47 Entries

I Voted for GORE!

78 Entries

I Want My DVD

54 Entries

It's a Major Award!

38 Entries

Legal Eaglese

18 Entries

Martial Artistry

6 Entries

Momentous Occasions

22 Entries

More On Movies

0 Entries

Musicalifornication

36 Entries

Sci-Fidelity

93 Entries

Separate but Sequel

191 Entries

Strike Watch

14 Entries

The Biz

115 Entries

The Casting Conch

165 Entries

The Kongs of Comedy

125 Entries

Top of the

0 Entries

Top of the MWoP

4 Entries

Trailer Trashing

54 Entries

We Call Do-Over

142 Entries

You Know, For Kids!

93 Entries