John Krasinski
Where You Know Him From: He plays Jim Halpert, office wisecracker and Michael's former co-manager on The Office.
Pro-America: At 6-foot 3, Krasinski is heroically tall, and while his lanky Jim is the epitome of the 98-pound-weakling archetype, he also played a believable pro football player in Leatherheads. Plus, as that movie showed, he can pull off a polite, "aw, shucks" persona that rings true with the old-fashioned Cap.
Anti-America: While classically handsome, he's certainly not the blonde, blue-eyed, square-jawed Cap that generations of fans have come to love. And his famously snarky attitude on The Office doesn't jive with the most optimistic and idealistic Avenger.

Chace Crawford
Where You Know Him From: As Nate Archibald, Crawford rules the Upper East Side of Manhattan with the rest of the cast of Gossip Girl.
Pro-America: His piercing blue eyes will make the mostly masked character come to life, as well as lining up the ladies around the block.
Anti-America: Since he's best known for playing a privileged high school student, we haven't really seen him in action, save for that time he had psychic powers in The Covenant. And it might be hard to buy such a pretty boy as the ultimate Super Soldier.

Scott Porter
Where You Know Him From: Formerly known as Jason Street on Friday Night Lights, Porter recently popped up on Caprica as a member of a polygamous marriage.
Pro-America: Everyone already knows him as a football player from America's heartland, and now he's dipping his toe into the sci-fi world, making him a viable contender. Plus, his statuesque features just scream "Steve Rogers" when he's got his hair cut properly.
Anti-America: Polygamous marriages? Danger, Will Robinson!

Michael Cassidy
Where You Know Him From: He had a run as Zach Stevens on The O.C., then one as Daily Planet editor Grant Gabriel on Smallville and most recently played Charlie Hogan on Privileged.
Pro-America: He has a clean-cut, all-American look about him, plus his relatively low-profile roles spare him a lot of the preconceived notions Krasinski and Crawford carry with them.
Anti-America: Outside of CW viewers, does anybody know who this guy is? The director has said he wants an unknown, but Cassidy's mediocre acting skills and unremarkable features don't exactly have us dying to see him as an action hero.

Patrick Flueger
Where You Know Him From: Flueger played Shawn Farrell on The 4400, and recently appeared in the drama Brothers.
Pro-America: The dude played a soldier in a highly regarded movie and wielded super powers on The 4400 -- Cap doesn't have any powers, of course, but that's got to count for something. Plus, cheekbones!
Anti-America: Although he's grown up a lot since The 4400, he still comes off looking a little boyish, even with a week's worth of stubble.

Wilson Bethel
Where You Know Him From: While he's famous for playing Cpl. Evan "Q-Tip" Stafford on Generation Kill, he's done six times as many episodes of The Young and the Restless playing Ryder Callahan, who actually sounds like a comic book character.
Pro-America: He's blond, he's already played a soldier and he has a chin you could cut glass with.
Anti-America: The guy's skinny enough to play a pre-serum Steve Rogers, but he'd have to bulk up something fierce to play Cap.

Mike Vogel
Where You Know Him From: In addition to past roles in the new Texas Chainsaw Massacre, Cloverfield and The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants, Vogel will also star as Dr. Chris DeLeo on the CBS drama Miami Medical when it premieres in April.
Pro-America: This proven film actor is blonde, blue-eyed and lantern-jawed. He might have this one in the bag.
Anti-America: "Vogel"... Is that a German name?

Which of these fellas do you think should be the next Captain America? And who should play Bucky? Sound off below