Black Swan vs. Center Stage: A Side-By-Side Comparison

In preparation for this Sunday's Golden Globes extravaganza, I finally got around to watching Black Swan a few nights ago. And while I was struck by how engrossing and visually stunning the movie is, I was also struck by how much it reminded me of another fine film about the plight of dancers: 2000's Center Stage, starring Zoe Saldana and Peter Gallagher. It may sound crazy, but really, it's a lot like Center Stage, if Center Stage grew up and then battled hardcore mental illness. Don't believe me? I've put forth the thematic similarities below. (Warning: Contains spoilers.)

Bulimic People
Ahh, bulimia and dancing movies. They go together like bulimia and gymnastics made-for-TV movies. Center Stage's Maureen would do anything it takes to be the perfect ballerina, including throwing up bowling alley pizza in the bowling alley and eating only iceberg lettuce for lunch. Black Swan's Nina Sayers has similar food issues (and she looks at beautiful pink grocery store cakes like they're edible tarantulas), but she takes it a step further and throws up after nearly every hallucination, whether she's eaten or not.

Mothers: The Worst!
Both Maureen and Nina's mothers were dancers who didn't make it for one reason or another and are now living through their daughters' successes by controlling their every move and really letting them know how much they resent them. On a trivial note, both mothers are also obsessed with their daughters' companies' front offices. Maureen's mother works in hers -- and seems to never leave it, except to supervise her daughter's lunch choices in the cafeteria -- and Nina's mother mentions talking to some secretary named Susan about 15 times in Black Swan. She talks about this Susan person almost as much as she barges in on her daughter in the bathroom, which is like every other scene.

Mean Company Directors
Center Stage's Jonathan tells ballerinas they're fat and sleeps with other people's girlfriends. Black Swan's Thomas is very French and quite gropey about it, particularly if your alternate personality starts hooking up with him behind your back.

Swan Lake
Black Swan's Swan Lake connection is obvious, but Center Stage referenced it as well. After Jonathan told Jody that her technique sucked and the other girls tried to brush technique off as less important than "heart" or something ridiculous, Maureen bitchily joked "Try dancing Swan Lake without [technique]!" And at the end, when Eva replaces Maureen in the final workshop, it's Swan Lake that she's dancing. Sure, it's the most well-known ballet to laymen, but still, worth pointing out.

The Bad Girl Whose Wild Ways Make Her an Unlikely Brilliant Dancer
Center Stage had Eva (played by a pre-Avatar -- but, more importantly, pre-Crossroads -- Zoe Saldana), the outspoken Latina who chewed gum in class and had the balls to only pull 3/4 of her hair back for rehearsals (major ballet offense), but was a brilliant dancer due to her non-conformist attitude really allowing her to dance "from the heart" (yes, that again). Black Swan's bad girl is Lily (Mila Kunis), who wears leather, says things like "Lighten up!" and pushes ecstasy on mentally unbalanced bunheads, but who ends up being just dangerous enough to be the perfect alternate to the goody-goody lead in Swan Lake.

A Wild Night Out
Elite dancers are under a lot of pressure. Naturally, at a certain point they're going to want to go out and blow off some steam (unless you're Maureen or Nina, in which case you'll have to be dragged out). In Center Stage's case, this results in margaritas with judgmental Jersey girls and salsa dancing with cougars. In Black Swan, it starts with a few narcotic-infused drinks and some casual conversations with single gents, and ends with blackout memory loss and a complete psychotic break.

The Seasoned Principal Everyone Tiptoes Around
Black Swan's is better, so I'll start with her. Winona Ryder's Beth Macintyre is a jilted dancer forced out of the company after years of service, so she releases the crazy and gets drunk at the company party, verbally attacks the new principal, then walks out into oncoming traffic and ends up with a broken everything, just to spite Thomas. Center Stage's Kathleen Donahue just kind of marries Jonathan and rolls her eyes at everybody a lot. Somehow, she's still the toast of the town, however.

Honorable Mention: Spontaneous Costume Transformations
In Black Swan's epic final scene, Nina spins around the stage as her arms increasingly transform into giant black wings that she unfurls like a massive, heaving, crazy, beautiful bird at the end of her performance. And hey, Center Stage had that one part where Jody's costume peeled off in pieces to transform a red leotard underneath. Same idea, just a difference in execution, really.

Anything I missed? Leave it in the comments, then see our list of Natalie Portman's best and worst roles!

What are people saying about your favorite shows and stars right now? Find out with Talk Without Pity, the social media site for real TV fans. See Tweets and Facebook comments in real time and add your own -- all without leaving TWoP. Join the conversation now!

25 Comments

January 13, 2011 5:12 PM
c
Reply

And the biggest difference between them: I will watch Center Stage whenever it's on tv. I will never watch Black Swan again.

January 13, 2011 5:20 PM
Holly
Reply

I loved Center Stage so much when I was in high school... Thanks for taking me back. :)

January 13, 2011 5:23 PM
Betsey
Reply

The major one you missed which I thought was shot for shot identical to Center Stage was the shoe preparation scene. When they are cutting out the lining, sewing on straps, scoring the soles, etc. IDENTICAL.

Also, regarding the black wings, I took that to be an hallicination (sp) that she was having. At the very end pose, from the audience's view, she doesnt have the wings, her shadow does.

January 13, 2011 7:39 PM
Kris
Reply

I haven't seen Black Swan yet, but there's no way that it's costume transformation is more impossible than Center Stage's. Jody ducks down during a live performance and (in less than a bar of music) comes up with a different leo, new makeup, a different hairdo, and new toe shoes!

January 13, 2011 7:52 PM
patty
Reply

i loved center stage. it made me wish i continued ballet for a bit when i watched it. i still catch it everytime i see it on tv

January 13, 2011 9:22 PM
DB
Reply

Just to nitpick: the performance Eva does isn't Swan Lake, it's an original piece by Jonathon.

January 14, 2011 9:18 AM
Sarah
Reply

I loved Center Stage and enjoyed Black Swan as well...I wish there were more ballet movies out there. I'm such a sucker for them!

January 14, 2011 9:18 AM
Sarah
Reply
replied to comment from Kris

I agree with Kris--that costume change was my biggest pet peeve with the movie! That could never happen!!

January 14, 2011 12:15 PM
val
Reply
replied to comment from DB

Agreed. With music by Rachmaninov, not Tchaikovsky. Swan Lake is shown much earlier in Center Stage -- during the gala scene.

January 14, 2011 2:54 PM
Jen
Reply

C is absolutely right.

January 15, 2011 3:31 AM
Zirze
Reply

Just to nitpick DB even more: it's an original piece by Christopher Wheeldon.

January 15, 2011 1:02 PM
mickey
Reply

Black Swan = good actors, mediocre dances
Center Stage = wonderful dancers, super bad actors (Ethan Steifel is a dream to watch dancing, but the man cannot act at all)

January 15, 2011 2:40 PM
b. lavine
Reply

Much better than either of these ballet movies was
The Red Shoes, years ago. Anyone remember?

January 15, 2011 5:19 PM
clarita
Reply

What about "The Company?" Another good ballet movie, with similarities.

January 16, 2011 12:16 AM
Amy
Reply
replied to comment from DB

Yeah I think that's right. But the group goes to see a part of Swan Lake near the beginning (the part where there are 4 dancers holding hands in a line moving across the stage)... and then it changes to Romeo and Juliet.

January 16, 2011 10:39 AM
alejandra
Reply

Eva doesn't dance swan lake in the workshop, she dances concert from Rachmaninoff... just saying

January 16, 2011 10:52 AM
Aggie
Reply

How about White Nights? I can't forget the scene where Mikhail Baryshnikov and Gregory Hines dance together - completely different styles, the same choreography. It was breath taking, and demonstrated, to me at least, the numerous facets of beauty.

January 16, 2011 1:17 PM
Kristen
Reply

The Turning Point, with Shirley McLaine, Ann Bancroft, Leslie Brown, and a shirtless Mikhail Baryshinikov at the height of his powers.

January 16, 2011 8:48 PM
MG
Reply
replied to comment from clarita

My favorite part about "The Company" was that the DVD let me just play the dances without having to slog through the awful "plot." LOVED the dancing in it.

January 16, 2011 10:22 PM
Jennifer A.
Reply
replied to comment from DB

No Eva does Swan Lake. Jody does an original by Cooper Nielson. I am only mildly ashamed that I know this.

January 17, 2011 8:20 PM
Lindsay
Reply

Eva doesn't do Swan Lake, the music she dances to is Rachmaninoff's 2nd, so it can't be Swan Lake.

January 18, 2011 8:28 AM
Cheryl
Reply
replied to comment from Betsey

Betsey, YES! I caught Center Stage on TV right after having seen Black Swan, and those shoe preparation scenes really are almost shot-for-shot identical. It really had me wondering whether Aronofsky ripped off... whoever it was that directed Center Stage.

January 18, 2011 9:49 AM
Sara
Reply
replied to comment from DB

Thank you! Was just going to comment on that.

January 18, 2011 10:06 AM
cdv102
Reply

And don't forget the scenes of seriously messed-up dancer feet.

And a ballerina staying at the studio by herself to practice after being told she wasn't good enough. In Black Swan, Nina. In Center Stage, Eva.

July 22, 2011 3:18 AM
Gucci Handbags
Reply

Some sites do nothing to police the products sold and do not know whether I can or that the content is not. At least one site (eBay) has a pretty good job, not everything is perfect, and false, to make it through the cracks.

Loading...

Add a comment

TWoP Toolbar

BLOG ARCHIVES

The Moviefile

January 2012

2 Entries

December 2011

27 Entries

November 2011

22 Entries

October 2011

22 Entries

September 2011

29 Entries

August 2011

27 Entries

July 2011

30 Entries

June 2011

25 Entries

May 2011

13 Entries

April 2011

23 Entries

March 2011

22 Entries

February 2011

33 Entries

January 2011

39 Entries

December 2010

21 Entries

November 2010

29 Entries

October 2010

23 Entries

September 2010

25 Entries

August 2010

26 Entries

July 2010

29 Entries

June 2010

36 Entries

May 2010

22 Entries

April 2010

26 Entries

March 2010

30 Entries

February 2010

19 Entries

January 2010

19 Entries

December 2009

15 Entries

November 2009

21 Entries

October 2009

27 Entries

September 2009

30 Entries

August 2009

28 Entries

July 2009

34 Entries

June 2009

27 Entries

May 2009

24 Entries

April 2009

23 Entries

March 2009

18 Entries

February 2009

30 Entries

January 2009

56 Entries

December 2008

51 Entries

November 2008

61 Entries

October 2008

102 Entries

September 2008

86 Entries

August 2008

99 Entries

July 2008

116 Entries

June 2008

95 Entries

May 2008

86 Entries

April 2008

67 Entries

March 2008

14 Entries