Oscars 2012: Our Gut Reactions to the Academy Award Nominations

Why is this man smiling?

Because The Artist -- in which John Goodman plays a big time movie producer -- was one of the big winners at this year's Oscar nominations, that's why. Michel Hazanavicius's homage to silent era Hollywood received a whopping ten nominations, including Picture, Actor, Director, Screenplay, Art Direction, Cinematography... basically, every category except for sound (obviously). But The Artist wasn't the film that received the most nominations this morning; that honor falls to another tribute to early cinema, Martin Scorsese's Hugo, which scored 11 nods, including Picture, Director and Screenplay and a host of technical categories, from cinematography, to editing, to visual effects. Other strong showings were made by Moneyball (6 nominations), War Horse (also six, albeit the bulk of those were for technical categories), The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo (five nominations, although again, those were mostly for technical categories), The Help and Midnight in Paris (both four nominations). The biggest surprises? Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close overcoming a critical lambasting and commercial indifference to secure a Best Picture nomination and the snubbing of critics' darling Albert Brooks in the Supporting Actor category for his image-redefining turn in Drive. Here's our gut reaction to the nominations for the major categories:

Best Picture
The Artist
The Descendants
Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close
The Help
Hugo
Midnight in Paris
Moneyball
The Tree of Life
War Horse

Nice to see Terrence Malick's magnum opus, The Tree of Life, make the final list of nine, even though it doesn't stand the slightest chance of winning. Same goes for surprise nominee Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close and the respected, but not beloved baseball drama, Moneyball. No, the race (if you can call it that, considering the way that a certain silent film is winning every award in sight) boils down to The Artist vs. The Descendants, with Hugo taking the dark (not war) horse slot. We like all three films quite a bit, but our vote would have to go to Hugo in that three-way race.

Directing
Michel Hazanavicius (The Artist)
Alexander Payne (The Descendants)
Martin Scorsese (Hugo)
Woody Allen (Midnight in Paris)
Terrence Malick (The Tree of Life)
The big missing names here are Steven Spielberg and David Fincher; while War Horse just squeaked into the Best Picture category, its legendary director was shut out. And although the DGA included Fincher amongst its nominees for The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, the Academy at large didn't agree. Their slots were most likely taken by respected veterans Woody Allen and Terrence Malick, neither of whom, if history serves, will bother to show up on Oscar night. While The Artist seems poised for an overall sweep, Scorsese could emerge victorious if the voters decide to spread the wealth around a little. Payne, meanwhile, will likely have to content himself with an Adapted Screenplay statue.

Actor in a Supporting role
Kenneth Branagh (My Week With Marilyn)
Jonah Hill (Moneyball)
Nick Nolte (Warrior)
Christopher Plummer (Beginners)
Max von Sydow (Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close)
As we mentioned up top, the lack of Albert Brooks in this category is, to borrow the title of another nominee's film, extremely sad and incredibly boneheaded. On the other hand, we're quite pleased that Nick Nolte was recognized for his soulful turn in the otherwise overlooked fight flick Warrior. And the fact that Jonah Hill now has an Oscar nomination to his name is funnier than anything in The Sitter. (Not that Hill is bad in Moneyball, mind you; it's just hard to believe that the dude that once starred in Grandma's Boy and Accepted is now an Oscar nominee.)

Actress in a Supporting Role
Bérénice Bejo (The Artist)
Jessica Chastain (The Help)
Melissa McCarthy (Bridesmaids)
Janet McTeer (Albert Nobbs)
Octavia Spencer (The Help)
Excuse us a moment while we squee with glee over Melissa McCarthy's well-deserved Oscar nod for her bold and hilarious performance in Bridesmaids. We've loved her since her days as the Dragonfly Inn's chef and it's a real thrill to see her emerging as a legit movie star. Even better, she has a real shot at winning -- while the leading actor statues generally go to dramatic performances, the supporting categories are more generous to comic turns; witness past wins by Marisa Tomei (My Cousin Vinny), Mira Sorvino (Mighty Aphrodite) and Kevin Kline (A Fish Called Wanda) among others. But McCarthy has a formidable opponent in Octavia Spencer, the breakout star of The Help, which is just as big a hit as Bridesmaids.

Actor in a Leading Role
Demián Bichir (A Better Life)
George Clooney (The Descendants)
Jean Dujardin (The Artist)
Gary Oldman (Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy)
Brad Pitt (Moneyball)
Largely ignored this awards season, the low-key spy thriller Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy roared back (in its typically quiet way) with a nomination for its star, Gary Oldman. The illegal immigration drama A Better Life proved to be the other little movie that could, picking up a nomination for leading man Demián Bichir. Though it always seemed like a long shot, we were hoping that Michael Shannon would make the cut for his extraordinary work in Take Shelter. Instead, we'll just prepare to be charmed by likely winner Jean Dujardin's acceptance speech.

Actress in a Leading Role
Glenn Close (Albert Nobbs)
Viola Davis (The Help)
Rooney Mara (The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo)
Meryl Streep (The Iron Lady)
Michelle Williams (My Week with Marilyn)
No surprises here at all. The only question now is, which celebrity impersonation will the voters choose to reward: Meryl Streep's Margaret Thatcher or Michelle Williams's Marilyn Monroe? Or could The Help's box office grosses power the widely loved Viola Davis to victory, just like The Blind Side's commercial success helped pave the way for Sandra Bullock's win two years ago?

Writing (Original Screenplay)
The Artist
Bridesmaids
Margin Call
Midnight in Paris
A Separation

Don't laugh, but Bridesmaids could rack up a win here if the Supporting Actress category goes to Octavia Spencer. Or if voters are feeling particularly political, Margin Call could seize on the Occupy Wall Street sentiment. In a perfect world, the brilliant Iranian drama A Separation would go home with the Oscar, but we're thrilled that it's at least in the running.

Writing (Adapted Screenplay)
The Descendants
Hugo
The Ides of March
Moneyball
Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy

Apart from Best Picture, this is the only category where The Descendants seems to have the best shot at winning. But don't count out Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy just yet, especially if literary titan John le Carré starts making the interview rounds praising the movie version of his seminal novel.

Animated Feature Film
A Cat in Paris
Chico & Rita
Kung Fu Panda 2
Puss in Boots
Rango

Steven Spielberg gets shafted again as his first foray into mo-cap animation, The Adventures of Tintin, is snubbed in favor of two cartoons (A Cat in Paris and Chico & Rita) that almost nobody has seen. The mighty animation house Pixar also gets shut out, though that's understandable considering the general crappiness of Cars 2. But yay for Rango, the movie that should -- and hopefully will -- win.

Foreign Language Film
Footnote
Bullhead
In Darkness
Monsieur Lazhar
A Separation

Oh, just give it to A Separation already and be done with it. You know you want to.

Click here to read our picks for Oscar's biggest snubs.

Think you're a TV or movie expert? Prove it! Play Trivia Without Pity, our new online trivia game with over 2,000 questions about the shows and films you love -- and love to hate.

What are people saying about your favorite shows and stars right now? Find out with Talk Without Pity, the social media site for real TV fans. See Tweets and Facebook comments in real time and add your own -- all without leaving TWoP. Join the conversation now!

TAGS:

25 Comments

January 24, 2012 11:36 AM
Rob
Reply

The only thing that I'm particularly unpleased about here is the Fassbender snub for Best Actor (and the Shame snub in general, but that one was expected). VERY happy that Tree of Life and A Separation got more recognition than expected, though.

January 24, 2012 11:47 AM
Jill
Reply

I'm kind of miffed that Shailene Woodley didn't get a nomination for supporting actess is The Descendants. I thought she was really, really excellent. I suppose that crummy TV show she's on must have turned people off.

January 24, 2012 12:12 PM
Josh
Reply

Terrible nominations. The Oscars really have become a joke and no longer care about rewarding the deserving films.

January 24, 2012 12:27 PM
Chrissysoll
Reply

Extremely loud got terrible reviews, how does that movie get nominated? Everyone is quick to jump on the McCarthy bandwagon but I really don't think she was THAT good. Better than Theron, Olson, Dunst? No way.

January 24, 2012 12:36 PM
rick
Reply
replied to comment from Chrissysoll

I agree that McCarthy's performance was way overrated, she did not beat out Theron, Olson or Dunst for a nomination. All three of those women would have vied for Best Actress, not Best Supporting Actress. And while I don't think much of McCarthy's performance or nomination, I do have to say I enjoy the bit of history that comes with it. I am fairly certain she is the only Oscar nominee ever whose nominated character shit themselves!

January 24, 2012 12:54 PM
Kate
Reply

I'm not surprised but very disappointed that Both Shame and 50/50 were ignored. They're both more controversial than the films that were nominated, but the Oscars should go to the best films/performances, not just the ones that are the most audience friendly.

January 24, 2012 12:55 PM
Debra
Reply

Forget A Cat in Paris and Chico &Rita. How on earth does Puss in Boots get a nomination over Tintin. It's absurd! Oh, well. At least Rango has nothing standing in its way now.

January 24, 2012 12:57 PM
Debra
Reply

The problem isn't so much that A Cat in Paris and Chico & Rita were nominated over Tintin. I've only seen clips, but they both look rather good. But how on earth does Puss in Boots get a nomination over Tintin?! It's absurd! Oh, well. At least Rango has nothing standing in its way now.

January 24, 2012 2:06 PM
Jill
Reply

Jonah Hill? Seriously? He was good, but not *that* good.

And for me, the biggest omission was Charlize Theron.

January 24, 2012 2:39 PM
Nemesis
Reply

"that almost nobody has seen.

Is this the measuring stick for Oscar-worthiness? It sure as hell shouldn't be.

As for Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close, that's the unfortunate kind of bullshit film that Oscar voters love. Schmaltzy, uninteresting, saying nothing new or important, but tear-jerking and flag-waving. Hey, if crap like The Blind Side could win a second-rate actress like Bullock an Oscar, why not this movie?

January 24, 2012 3:08 PM
Ed
Reply

Why no love for Ryan Gosling? He KILLED in "Ides of March," as did both Paul Giamatti and Philip Seymour Hoffman in their supporting roles.

January 24, 2012 3:09 PM
liaso
Reply

[i]"The Artist...basically, every category except for sound (obviously)"[/i] I wouldn't say "obviously". The sound in The Artist was used extremely well. I remember a few scenes in particular that the sound was integral to the plot of the film. So while it doesn't jump out to someone who hasn't seen the film, a sound nomination would actually be very fitting for the film.

January 24, 2012 3:51 PM
George
Reply

I really wish the Academy would have the cojones to nominate something like Bridesmaids for Best Picture instead of such obvious Oscar-bait like Bore Horse and Extremely Long and Incredibly Monotonous...

January 24, 2012 7:30 PM
arial
Reply

After seeing Julie and Julia, and now The Iron Lady, I'm beginning to worry that, in all fairness, they'll have to create a whole new category pitting Meryl Streep against her own past performances. She's so much better than any other actor out there, it's just not fair to make others compete against her. And I loved her humility (and insight into her vulnerability and apparent work ethic) at the Golden Globes, when she forgot her glasses. It seemed memorizing lines (in that case, thank you speeches) is not her forte, yet she's always perfect in her roles.

January 24, 2012 8:06 PM
Justin
Reply
replied to comment from Nemesis

I'd really wish people would stop saying Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close is uninteresting, saying nothing new or important. It's a portrayal of a mildly autistic boy dealing with the death of his father in the only way he knows how. The movie is a about a boy who could never seem to find any sort of connection from his life to others, and in trying to find where something fits, he realizes there is a much deeper human connection, something his father unknowingly teaches him from beyond the grave. So it may not work entirely as a 9/11 film, but as a film about a misunderstood boy just trying to find a place and understand something that really can’t always be understood, it does. These people criticizing the movie such as yourself are insulting and obviously completely missing the mark.

January 24, 2012 8:40 PM
Denise
Reply
replied to comment from Nemesis

But if they don't nominate Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close, the terrorists will win...

January 24, 2012 10:05 PM
Slizzard
Reply

Harry Potter 8 should have been nominated for best picture. Yeah, it shouldn't have won, but it should have been recognized, because it was good. Sadly, it was fantasy.

Snubs I hate: Michael Fassbender (that might be the biggest offender/surprise. It must have been political. He's not in the in-crowd yet). Charlize Theron. Shailene Woodley. Ryan Gosling. Drive for best picture. Albert Brooks. Grr. anger

January 24, 2012 10:14 PM
texphile
Reply
replied to comment from Denise

That must be it... I saw the trailers and it looks like a hamhanded tearjerker. I actually like Tom Hanks as an actor. He seems to know his range and doesnt act like every thing he does is an epic on the level of Saving Private Ryan ... this one I have avoided though. Seems like a rental/discount theater film to me.

January 25, 2012 12:04 AM
Lorelai
Reply

How I long for more nominations for Tinker, Tailor. It was so, so good, y'all.

January 25, 2012 8:57 AM
panjee
Reply

i was abit saddened that melancholia wasnt included (though we know the reason behind it)... i agree that kirsten dunst should be included... she was punished for being in afilm directed by a nazi sympathizer :-(

January 25, 2012 11:23 AM
ChaChaHeels
Reply
replied to comment from Justin

Yes, but couldn't this story about an autistic boy trying to connect and learning how to do so from his dead father have been told without jingo-ism? It's the fact that the whole 9/11 event has to sell the movie at all that makes every know the film is all slimy manipulation, no substance.

January 25, 2012 4:51 PM
Karen
Reply
replied to comment from ChaChaHeels

So American movies should just ignore that 9/11 happened? That so many lives changed, that there are so many stories that start with those horrible hours, but can be uplifting should be the main criteria. It looks like a 3-hanky flick, so that's why I haven't gone yet. But 9/11 is the starting point, not the story itself.

January 25, 2012 6:45 PM
Molly
Reply

The only snub that really bumbed me out was Albert Brooks. I though he had a real shot.

February 26, 2012 12:41 PM
Marissa
Reply

Madman, you sure know how to take the fun out of a blog mela. Take your rules and ipsome them where the sun don't shine. Bah!

February 28, 2012 3:22 AM
aikol
Reply

smnooee January 23, 2009 Did you base number 8 entirely on that Yahoo! Answers thing? Because Yahoo! Answers is clogged with the stupidest people capable of using the internet.Some memorable questions include How do I scan a mirror and use it as my background , Where can I find scuba-diving equipment for my horse and I heard on TV that there's a war in Georgia, when do we evacuate (The person lived in the state Georgia of the US, the war was in the country Georgia halfway across the world.) It's also likely that a lot of the people there are being asses on purpose.Yeah, this post's main purpose was just to rant on Yahoo! Answers ) But I think our reputation is more on being ignorant and too prideful. Not to mention kurakot.

Loading...

Add a comment

TWoP Toolbar

BLOG ARCHIVES

The Moviefile

April 2012

12 Entries

March 2012

26 Entries

February 2012

24 Entries

January 2012

25 Entries

December 2011

27 Entries

November 2011

22 Entries

October 2011

22 Entries

September 2011

29 Entries

August 2011

27 Entries

July 2011

30 Entries

June 2011

25 Entries

May 2011

13 Entries

April 2011

23 Entries

March 2011

22 Entries

February 2011

33 Entries

January 2011

39 Entries

December 2010

21 Entries

November 2010

29 Entries

October 2010

23 Entries

September 2010

25 Entries

August 2010

26 Entries

July 2010

29 Entries

June 2010

36 Entries

May 2010

22 Entries

April 2010

26 Entries

March 2010

30 Entries

February 2010

19 Entries

January 2010

19 Entries

December 2009

15 Entries

November 2009

21 Entries

October 2009

27 Entries

September 2009

30 Entries

August 2009

28 Entries

July 2009

34 Entries

June 2009

27 Entries

May 2009

24 Entries

April 2009

23 Entries

March 2009

18 Entries

February 2009

30 Entries

January 2009

56 Entries

December 2008

51 Entries

November 2008

61 Entries

October 2008

102 Entries

September 2008

86 Entries

August 2008

99 Entries

July 2008

116 Entries

June 2008

95 Entries

May 2008

86 Entries

April 2008

67 Entries

March 2008

14 Entries