Harry and Mr. Matthews confront the lacrosse team about their pig prank. They all play dumb until Harry says that he'll have to cancel their season if no one steps up.
Adrianna tells Naomi that she's ready for her audition, although it doesn't seem likely. They discuss how everyone at school is talking about Naomi and George's makeout session too.
Harry yells at Dixon in his office, and tries to get him to rat out his team. Dixon can't believe his father would ask him to do that, but finally admits to pulling the prank, and claims he did everything himself. Harry knows he's lying, and Dixon brings up Harry's similar prank. Harry wants to make sure that Dixon wants to take all the responsibility for this, and Dixon says there's no question.
Adrianna sits in the waiting room for her audition and silently freaks out, so she gets up and leaves before her name is even called.
Silver pumps Annie for info on her date with Ty. Annie notices that Silver has the same tattoo as Naomi and asks about it. Silver (who is wearing a hideous aqua head wrap thing) confesses that in eighth grade, she found out that her dad was having an affair with her mom's best friend, but she didn't want to say anything because she didn't want her parents to get divorced. Finally, she told her best friend Naomi, who told everyone. Annie wonders why Naomi would do that, and Silver says that Naomi just needs to have power over people. Silver says that her parents got divorced anyway, and now she wants Naomi to pay for it.
Adrianna returns to school and Matthews asks her about the audition. Adrianna lies that it went great and she might get the part. Matthews seems to know that something's up.
Ethan thanks Dixon for taking the fall, even though he got cut from the team. Dixon walks away, and Ethan walks up to Harry and admits that he helped with the prank. Navid admits that the pigs are his.
Debbie found a matchbook from the restaurant in San Francisco in Annie's pocket. She is the worst sneaker-outer ever. Never leave evidence! Debbie refuses to apologize for being angry about this, even though Annie tries the "everyone else does it" excuse. Debbie wants to trust her daughter, but she can't right now.
Peach Pit. Naomi and Ethan meet up, and Ethan rips into her for hooking up with George. Naomi reminds him that he cheated on her first. Ethan is kind of sick of the back and forth, and says that he thinks he cheated because he wants out of their relationship. Then the cheesiest line of the episode: Naomi asks if he's breaking up with her and Ethan says, "I'm breaking up with us." GROOOOOOAN!