This all plunges Jude back into a flashback to 1949, back when Judy was a club singer with a band. And that band included Terry, who is knocking on her door, wondering where she was last night. She very clearly was All of the Drunk last night, but she tries to make excuses. Terry, by the way, is played by Sean Patrick Thomas of Save the Last Dance fame. God help me, but I think they're supposed to be the same age in this scene. He tells her the gig went pretty okay, as "Barry" (Terry and Barry?) called his cousin to fill in. And I guess she did pretty okay, because Terry has an envelope full of see-ya-later cash for Judy. She reacts as you might expect. "Barry's been trying to get his fat cousin in there for months now," she grouses. She starts shouting about conspiracies, but he can only look down at her sadly and say he's sorry. She even tries coming on to him, offering to make him feel "real good" and saying she's always wondered what it would be like with a "colored man." Aw, jeez. Look away, everybody. He finally shuts her down ("You smell of vomit!") and gives her a definite goodbye. As he does though, he mentions that in the Kiss-Off Envelope, there's a card from a detective looking for her, asking questions about a hit-and-run. Then Terry's like, "Peace!" and Judy starts freaking out because They Found Her. She hurries to pack her shit, leaves the rent money on the nightstand and hightails it the hell away. With her windshield still cracked! Hell of a police force in this town. As she speeds away, she's tormented by flashbacks to that night of the accident. She's boozing again while she does it and she ends up crashing her car... again. When she comes to, she sees an angel. Not Frances Conroy. A white angel. Made of stone, in fact. She managed to crash into a tree at the local convent. Organ music plays on the soundtrack and the beams of sunlight surrounding the statue make it pretty hard for Judy not to see this as a sign.
Back in the here and now, Jude's memories are interrupted by a call from Devil Eunice, who is feeling whimsical enough to tell Sister Jude that it's her conscience calling. Jude asks Eunice what she's done. Eunice is like, "Ohhhh, more like what did YOU do?" She tells Jude what she already knows: that the hotel room has been decked out with paraphernalia from a 15-year-old hit-and-run case. Sister Jude asks how she knew and Devil Eunice replies that she knows everything. "I was in your head, remember?" Jude does remember: that boy with the devil inside him, how the demon was cast out and Sister Mary Eunice was knocked flat on her back. On the phone, Eunice suggests Sister Jude start running now. Though, she muses, how far does she think she can even go. Instead, she's left a bottle of "Kentucky something-or-other" and a razor blade on the nightstand. You know, in case Judy feels particularly enterprising.