American Idol
American Idol

Episode Report Card
Jacob Clifton: C | 494 USERS: C+
YOU GRADE IT
Arrival Of A Train At A Station
In a hurry? Read the recaplet for a nutshell description!

One hundred thousand hopes dashed, and now it's all happening: girl versus guy versus machine. One last chance to vote, one last episode full of pointless filler and one hell of a crappy coronation song. This is the night, this is the audience, this is...the death of culture." I'm paraphrasing. But in the audience there is much cheering and Pounding of Dawgs, and into the Kodak we are welcomed one penultimate time. Other boy/girl fights are mentioned: From Justin to Kelly and on into Bo and Carrie, Taylor and "Kat," and now all of a sudden we got Blake and Jordin. My favorite things. Randy Jackson is dressed like Sergeant Pepper on a bender, bejeweled and bechained and bespoke and befoolish. Paula's hair and outfit once again jostle at the Wearstler elbow, and inside her head it's just a parade of trumpeting crazy. Simon looks exactly the same as he always has and always will: like the swinger cokehead manager at a particularly tony restaurant with $15 martinis and everyone on the waitstaff is five foot even, so they appear to scurry. Ryan calls him "Simon Cleavage," hilariously not, and Paula traces one creepy finger along his low-rise t-shirt and then won't let go of his hand. If the shirt's getting attention, she's on it. Ryan asks what happened, and the short version is, she tripped last night on a Chihuahua named Tulip and busted her nose -- this is not of my invention -- then got crazy fast plastic surgery and now looks exactly the same as she did before. She goes, "Simon says the new nose is sexier," all twisting the knife, and you know Seacrest ain't having it: "So the bitch is okay, we got it." Now, normally I'd say this is Ryan being awkward at an inconvenient time, but no: you mess with the bull, you get the gelled-up, well-manicured, bitchy little horns. Don't insert yourself into that mess, Paula, no matter how many cameras are pointed at it. Simon and Randy are like whoa, but you can't hide the tiny little smile on Simon's face. This has got to be American Idol: the bitterness, the free-flowing alcohol and pretense that everything is normal, that added soupçon of barely contained gay rage mean it's either AI, or Thanksgiving dinner Chez Clifton. And we're months from the holidays! "It's ironic," says Ryan, understating as all get out, "that the town to get press for all the wrong reasons is now famous for the right reasons!" This doesn't make a hell of a lot of sense because the world still doesn't hate Seattle as much as I do, so we must infer he's talking about the tiny little square foot world of this show, in which at some point Seattle did something foul to Ryan Seacrest.

American Idol