Dominique is next. Tyra likes her booty tooch, and Paulina thinks it's nice as well. Nigel says that she nailed it for the first time. I love how the judges always say the exact opposite of what Jay says during the shoots. Stacy-Ann is next. She looks like an amputee. Nigel notes that at the party she seemed quite fake, and like she was presenting something. He wants her to be more natural and normal. Paulina agrees, and says that she was like a human car show at the party. Jay gives Stacy-Ann credit for managing a decent photo with the tearing eyes. Tyra tells Stacy-Ann that she needs how to work her strong jaw. Then there's Whitney. Jay thinks it's the most natural looking shot for her, whereas when she was in the featured spot during the shoot it was "so pageantry." Tyra thinks she could be a little less America's Next Top Miss America, and Nigel tells her that she was the other person at the party who came off as fake. Whitney appears to be gobsmacked. Paulina notes that Whitney could use a little of Lauren in her, and vice versa.
Anya is next. She worked the room at the party and was herself, which Nigel loved. Tyra didn't expect Anya to do well at the party, given her whack accent, but was proven wrong. Her best shot is pretty great. Jay says that no matter what position she was in, she stood out. Nigel likes it as well. And then there's Fatima, who doesn't have a picture. So she gets no commentary, and we head straight to the judges' deliberation! But not before learning that Lauren is the Cover Girl of the Week! Hoping that Fatima would choke on a cup of coffee and all!
Okay, deliberations. Katarzyna's shot is great, but generally she's forgettable. Miss J. still thinks that Dominique looks like a man, but a fab man. Lauren looks graceful in her picture, but she doesn't make sense to Nigel in person. Jay, however, believes in Lauren after seeing her confidence week after week on set. Paulina does, too. Whitney has great energy in her picture, according to Paulina, but Nigel was totally unimpressed with her personality at the party. Miss J. thinks that Stacy-Ann is losing her sparkle and glitter. Nigel agrees that she's plateaued, at a time when she really needs to be raising the bar. Anya stole the show according to some judges, but Tyra doesn't think her picture is all that great. Fatima has no photo, so the judges reflect on her body of work. She went from homeless to lingerie to paint to fetus to vampire meat lover. With that trajectory in mind, the judges have reached a decision.