Sophie is next. Cutrone loves the silhouette and outfit, but isn't crazy about Sophie's face. She does make a comparison to Debbie Harry, which is apt if you think of Debbie Harry with a wonky eye. Georgina loves it, though, and enjoys the fact that it's slightly off. Finally, there's Annaliese. Nigel loves her body, but doesn't like what she's doing with her face. Cutrone agrees, and says that she's a fan from the neck down, but wants to bid hasta la vista to everything above the neck. Georgina, however, likes the deadness in Annaliese's face. Well, look who she's married to! Tyra agrees with Georgina, and says that she likes the photo. Cutrone asks if Georgina would put it in the Marchesa look book, and Georgina says that she might. That is actually a very polite "no," but still.
The judges deliberate. Catherine really wants to be a model, but Cutrone isn't sure that she is. Also, her walk sucks, in the manner of someone who has been drugged and escaped from a hospital. At least she didn't trip? Seymone is an incredible-looking girl in an amazing gown, says Nigel, but before he can finish Cutrone tells everyone about how rude and pissy she was doing the challenge. Cutrone also calls her out as being particularly painful on the runway, and Georgina notes that she doesn't connect modeling from her face to her body. Tyra thinks that Seymone's face in her photo is one of the strongest, but overall it's too much show and tell modeling. Alisha is finally starting to stand out, and Cutrone calls her a superstar. Nigel reminds everyone that she can also look wretched, and Tyra hopes that the good photo is not a fluke.
Laura's shot is cool and fun, but Nigel has seen it already from her. Cutrone agrees that she's a bit of a one trick pony. Georgina wishes that she'd had more humor in her face, but thinks she did a good job. Eboni's shot is good from the neck down, but Cutrone also hates her face. Cutrone also adds that she was disappointed upon seeing Eboni at the challenge not wearing ponytails. Okay, I get the 30-Never thing, but she has to wear ponytails ALL THE TIME? That's just annoying. Georgina thinks that Eboni looks sweet in her shot, but also a bit worried. Cutrone loves Sophie, but isn't so into her face in her photo. Georgina adds that Sophie was good in the fashion show, and looked like a real model. Tyra likes Sophie's photo and its hint of pissed-off-ness. Cutrone says that Annaliese's photo is like a Carnival Cruise ad, but does give her props for her performance in the runway show. Nigel likes the body shot, but still thinks that her face needs work. With that, the judges have reached a decision!