Later that evening, Adam and Ryan call Sheila out, saying something's up with her. She wants to go find the Bible right now, so everyone can swear on it, and of course her predictably overwrought reaction just makes Ryan more certain that something's fishy with her. Later, outside, he and Adam play mini-golf while trying to figure out how Sheila could be related to Sharon. Inside, Sheila and Sharon talk about who voted Natalie out. Sheila wonders who the renegade voter was, but Sharon claims to know. With Adam going in and out, Sharon and Sheila covertly discuss the vote that just happened. Sheila, naturally, is taking Adam's defection personally. And meanwhile, outside, Ryan and Adam talk about Ryan's power as the "biggest HoH yet." Ryan's glad he can nominate based on who he thinks is bullshitting him. Which makes Adam nervous, as intended.
Ryan's HoH room turns out to not have any pictures of Sheila with Ryan's family, much to Sheila's relief. Ryan reads his letter from Jen, in which she claims to be watching him on the live feeds 24/7, although in a nice way. Ryan is, in the manner of all HoHs, freshly motivated.
Adam decides to start talk like a robot for a while, just for fun. "Can you get any more annoying?" Sheila wonders. Adam keeps it up so long and gets on Sheila's nerves so much that somehow it actually comes around to funny. Hey, nobody's more embarrassed to admit that than me.
Sheila goes to Adam and gets him to promise to save her. Adam noncommittally agrees, and doesn't even seem impressed when Sheila claims she'd rather end her own game before Adam's. Try threatening him some more, Sheila. That always seems to work.
Up in the HoH room, Adam and Ryan discuss over Ryan's snacks what Adam said to Natalie before her eviction. Ryan still suspects Adam of telling her, "I voted for you," but Adam is maintaining that he only said, "What do you want me to do?" The editors have Ryan's back here, though, playing the relevant clip complete with subtitles under Adam. And those subtitles read, "I voted for you," even though the audio there isn't any clearer than with the guinea pigs. Ryan claims to believe Adam to his face, but in the DR he remains unconvinced and pissed off. And Adam is worried that he made a big mistake.