In the backyard, everyone but Natalie realizes Natalie's lying, and they think it's something good having to do with final two reversal. Kevin says anyone would be an idiot to take her to final two. Natalie comes out and Kevin asks her to break it down. She plays dumb. Well, she is dumb, but she plays dumber. She asks them to please not ask her anything more about Pandora's box. Kevin asks why, and she says it's just a request she has: "Don't ask me about it." Kevin goes inside, and Natalie follows. Michele and Jordan wish they knew what it was. Kevin goes to the HoH room, and tells her his theory: It's like mystery power over again. He says it's not adding up because she'd be breaking windows if she just lost $500,000.
Natalie DRs that she needs to come clean, but not in a way like she was trying to lie, but just to make it seem like it was all a fun joke. She comes downstairs and says they all got got by an 18-year-old because she just pranked them all. She's like, "You all just believed me, right?" Michele's like, "Uh, no, idiot." Kevin also agrees. She says she got good news, and then she tells the truth. Jordan doesn't believe her now, and Natalie's all, "Where do you think I got this twisty ring from?" Kevin points to the kitchen, "Right over here." She wants them to admit she got them. Michele thinks it's still bizarre world that she decided to prank them after getting proposed to. Natalie says she got herself out of hot water, but no one else looks like she's out. Kevin confirms it in the DR, saying if she'd lie about good news, what wouldn't she lie about? He says he bets she's been lying the entire game, and that her name's not even Natalie. Well... he's getting close. Now we get an America's Vote: Reward your favorite houseguest $25,000 in cash. All the houseguests are there, so it's not just jury members this time. [Do you think Braden will get any votes? - Angel] Winner will be announced at the finale. I would have said Jeff was a lock, but maybe Casey has a chance.
Natalie explains her duty of nominating two houseguests for eviction. This is all filler, even more than usual, because nothing matters but the PoV. But whatever. I'll humor you all by telling you what happens anyway. Natalie looks at the wall. Michele's all, "Who cares? There's no one to choose from." Jordan sort of believes Natalie's lie that she's safe, because Kevin and Michele are her targets, but she also remembers that Jeff told her to stick with Michele and not to believe anything Kevin or Natalie said. So, see? He wouldn't admit it to Julie last episode, but he knew he shouldn't have believed the lie about Russell. Kevin's totally in on Natalie's scheme to put him up, but he doesn't know if she'll follow through because she's a liar. The fact that he knows he's such a liar makes me want him in the jury, because he knows her well enough to not want to vote for her. Natalie's hoping to hide loyalties and allegiances she has with these nominations.