Commercial break, during which we will discuss some of what's wrong with that last scene. Let's place aside the obvious: that no teacher would ever bring a real gun to his classroom, or use it to terrorize his students, just to make a point. (The fact that he does not get fired, let alone arrested, for this, we'll also choose to ignore, at least for now.) And, furthermore, let's place aside that he's making this point to kids whose behavior doesn't suggest that they need it, as the worst we've seen them do is blatantly not pay attention, and the worst we've heard of them doing is throwing spitballs. I mean, if these are the worst kids at the school, then this show is beyond cowardly, too afraid to show any student as truly dangerous or actually beyond hope, because my God does it ever get that bad in real classrooms. Unless this really does take place in the fifties. Does it? But let's place all of that aside and concentrate on the actual message that Mr. Senate is trying to get across. If these are, as the show seems to want us to believe, "desegs" being bussed in from a dangerous urban area, then theirs is not a fascination with violence born of media portrayals that make it look cool. Violence is a reality of their daily lives. They respect guns not because they get a kick out of The Sopranos, but more likely because they've seen friends get shot. That's why they cower and weep when you fire the thing, idiot. That's why they don't cheer at how cool you are instead. And, by the way, moron, make up your mind. Are you chastising them for finding guns entertaining, or taking them to task for only respecting the threat of violence? Because those messages contradict each other: people who respect guns don't think they're cool, and people who think guns are cool aren't really respecting them. You can't accuse people of both at the same time. And, frankly, what's wrong with respecting guns because they can kill you? So, quite apart from the Herculean suspension of disbelief required to buy his actions, nothing Mr. Senate says makes any sense either. Basically, Mr. Senate, shut up. ("David, I'm wearing that lingerie you like. Just have him fire the gun, and talk about The Godfather." "You're a genius, dear. Give me those handcuffs.")
Boston Public
Episode Report Card
511 USERS: C+
YOU GRADE IT
Boston Public













Comments