Spike sits next to the keg, which oddly enough doesn't have a huge crowd around it. One of the commandos tells him that he "looks familiar," but Spike just agrees that he hears that often. The commando looks at him curiously.
It's Xander's turn to spin the bottle and it ends up pointing to Julie, the craggy, overly made-up redhead in pink. He looks around and steels himself to give her a quick peck on the cheek. The surrounding circle giggles in approval, but Julie suddenly tackles Xander and clambers onto his lap, kissing him wildly. Xander grabs her arms and pushes her face from his, asking what's going on. Julie suddenly looks terrified and, saying that she's sorry, she gets up and runs away. After a moment of confusion, Xander gets up to follow her. He searches for her throughout the party but instead runs across Preppy Girl, shouting ecstatically and taking another turn at the orgasm wall. A circle of people surrounds her, each waiting to take their turn. Xander then hears crying in a closet and rattles the door handle. Inside we see Julie weeping and repeating "I'm bad, I'm bad" as she cuts of her hair with what looks like scissors or a knife.
Willow knocks at the bathroom door, calling to Tara, and then enters. She looks around the empty bathroom and then runs some water in the sink to rinse her face. As she dries off, she hears the same muffled noise that Riley did and approaches the same drawn shower curtain. She pulls the curtain aside and sees a boy under the water in the tub, his arms crossed over his chest, struggling to breathe. Willow grabs for the boy but he vanishes as soon as her hands touch the water. She looks scared and then turns to find the corpsey-looking boy standing right behind her. Willow screams. Nearby, Buffy and Riley are hot and heavy, still stuffin' the baked potato, if you know what I mean, and I think you do. Riley asks if it was Willow screaming and Buffy replies, "I don't know. It doesn't matter." Wanton spud-loving hussy.
Downstairs, the spin-the-bottle game is still in progress. Xander tries to tell them that Julie is having a hard time, but the bottlers don't really listen and just continue to giggle at their game. Willow races down the stairs, calling for Tara, and finds Xander. She explains about the ghost boy in the tub and how she tried to save him. Xander exclaims, "Is every frat on this campus haunted? And if so, why do people keep coming to these parties? 'Cause it's not the snacks." Tara finds them and looks apologetically at Willow, saying that she thinks they should leave the house. The spin-the-bottlers shout happily but the bottle they are playing with starts to spin more and more quickly until it explodes into shards. The players clutch their eyes and run away screaming. Willow, Tara, and Xander decide they need Buffy and race up the stairs to Riley's room. As they pound on the door and shout, giant rubber Alaska King Crab legs poke out from under the door and wave about in a silly manner. Oh, my bad, I guess those are supposed to be vines. We are treated to a ceiling-cam shot of Buffy and Riley, frantically kissing in bed. The camera pulls up and up and up, until the bed is just a tiny square of blue adrift in a black background. The World's Smallest Porn Set, as one of Sep's friends observed. At one point, as Sars pointed out on the boards, Marc Blucas does indeed start to stick his hand between Sarah Michelle Gellar's legs (outside the sheets), but then thinks better of it and awkwardly moves his hand up to her back.