Nursing Home. Hallway. Phoebe walks out, followed by the hard Ps and Leo. She looks over at some old men playing cards in the rec room. She reasons aloud that the "bright side" to this sitch is "not ending up in a place like this in [her] old age." Phoebe, SHUT UP. Not all senior citizens are deaf. And this nursing home doesn't look like a fate worse than death either. Jeez. Phoebe reasons that they still have to do something before midnight, when her past life will catch up with her, if not sooner. Leo tells Phoebe she'll "have to go back to the past again" to get some answers.
Halliwell Manor. Phoebe walks into the parlor with the BoS. Leo tells her to make sure she gets back before Pre-Phoebe is strangled, or they won't be able to wake her up. Phoebe tells him not to worry, and reiterates the "past life" spell. She falls back onto the sofa, in another trance.
1920s Halliwell Manor. The case of liquor is blown up in the backyard. Anton asks Pre-Phoebe, "Feels good to be bad, doesn't it?" Pre-Pheebs has second thoughts, since she'll be taking down her cousins. He reminds her that her amulet will protect her from the Pre-hard Ps' powers. Anton paints a rosy future for the two of them after they gain those powers and become "unstoppable." Anton and Pre-Pheebs neck some more. Anton tells her about his plan to distract Pre-Piper by disguising himself as her former lover. He wipes a hand across his face and turns into pre-Leo. What? This completely doesn't allow for Leo's final past life before becoming a White Lighter to be a serviceman in World War II -- he would either have been too young or too old. But, hey, time plays cruel tricks on the writers of this show and they pass them on to the viewers, I guess.
Parlor. At a microphone a singer croons, "If you were the only girl in the world, and I was the only boy . . ." Pre-Dan apes piano-playing in accompaniment. Pre-Piper watching the performance, sees fake Pre-Leo in the foyer. She wonders what he's doing there. He grabs her. She asks what's wrong -- this isn't like him. He agrees, and wipes the face off his head (tm Parker Posey in Dazed and Confused) to reveal that he's Anton. Meanwhile, in the sunroom, Pre-Phoebe walks up to Pre-Prue. She asks her cousin to talk with her upstairs. But Pre-Prue hears Pre-Piper being assaulted. The easily-startled speakeasy patrons start to bug out and run out the door. Anton struggles with Pre-Piper. Pre-Dan rushes to her assistance. Anton flings him back against the fireplace in the parlor. Pre-Piper puts Anton in slow motion (which I guess is Piper's unevolved power). But Anton quickly moves back to normal speed, and continues attacking her. The little girl runs up the stairs and watches the action below. Pre-Prue throws an icicle beam at Pre-Pheebs. What the? How did this "Mr. Cold Mizer" power evolve into Prue's telekinesis? Whatever! Pre-Phoebe's amulet glows, protecting her from Pre-Prue's frostiness. Pre-Pheebs asks her cousin how it feels "to be powerless against [her]." Pre-Prue distracts her with a camera flash and hurls her body at Pre-Phoebe as she ducks from the fireball Pre-Pheebs has shot in her direction. Pre-Piper knees Anton in the balls and pulls a grandfather clock on top of him. The pre-lazy Ps wrestle each other on the parlor room floor. The little girl watches all of this. Cut to an exterior shot of extras running out of the manor in horror. Meanwhile, inside, Pre-Piper grabs a curtain sash and puts it around pre-Phoebe's neck. Pre-Pheebs struggles on the floor while both her cousins try to strangle her. Pre-Prue grabs the amulet from her neck and throws it into the foyer. The little girl sees this. While Pre-Piper holds Pre-Pheebs' neck in the rope, Pre-Prue reaches into her garter belt for the written spell. The Pre-hard Ps declare that Pre-Pheebs is "evil" and they must stop her and Anton "in this life, and in any life." Pre-Piper asks God to "forgive" them, probably for the amateurish Hallmark verse the two of them recite: Evil witch in my sight/ Vanquish thyself/ Vanquish thy might/ In this and every future life. Pre-Phoebe glares at them as she chokes to death.