Casey shows them a strip of mall pictures of the young Alex Coburn and a young girl. He says she was the love of his life, Kathleen, and he gave her up and now 20 years later they're threatening her. If Casey doesn't show up at the meet, they'll do it. Sarah decides to have Chuck go to Kathleen's and sneak her out to safety. Casey says Chuck didn't even know he was Alex Coburn until today. Chuck: "I don't care who you were. I know who you are." Casey and Sarah head to the meet, but when he arrives, he's alone. He lights a Cuban and leaves the matchbook with some matches sticking up when they take him to see Robert Patrick. Meanwhile, Chuck arrives at Kathleen's and pretends he's with the gas company. He says there's a leak and they need to leave, but Ring guys show up and he says the gas leak is outside so she must go back inside. She's obviously concerned and tells him it's getting weird. He apologizes and then locks her in the closet as she kicks and screams. He watches the Ring guys approach.
Back with Casey. He finds Robert Patrick alone in a room. He asks "Alex" if he has the Laudinol, and Casey pulls out the pill case. Robert Patrick knew he could count on him, because good soldiers always follow orders. He tells Casey he wouldn't be in this mess if he would have stopped caring about Kathleen 20 years ago like he told him to. He opens the pill case and finds a Tic Tac. He asks what the hell this is, and Casey snarls, "Your breath stinks." Robert Patrick asks if Casey thinks he's going to just walk out of here with the five men outside. "The one thing I always taught you: 'Make sure you have someone watch your back.' " Yeah, dude, Casey knows. Outside, Sarah lowers herself from her hiding place under the car and counts five matches sticking up on Casey's matchbook. "Five against one," she says, then starts shooting and throwing knives at guards standing around the car. She jumps out and awesomely takes them on. Casey and Robert Patrick fight inside. Yvonne is fantastic at really selling what a bad-ass Sarah is, because she takes out these guys much more easily than Casey takes Robert Patrick, who pleads that Kathleen will die if he kills him. Casey's too smart for that and says, "You'd never call them off." To his credit, Robert Patrick agrees. So, Casey picks him up with his hand and smashes his throat. Sarah watches sort of horrified, and Casey seethes that they're already at the house.