Deb and Quinn question Jordan about his connection with the missing Cole, Boyd and now Alex Tilden. Meanwhile, Lumen and Dexter plot to get Jordan, and it's all very lovey-dovey. Lumen asks Dexter if Deb has ever suspected anything about him. He says she has a blind spot when it comes to him. Then, his baby monitor picks up the signal of the camera that Liddy has planted in the apartment. Liddy tells Quinn that he wants help getting his job back. Quinn refuses.
Dexter finds the camera, which has a "property of the police" sticker on it. He tells Lumen that they have to lie low, but she is anxious to continue their vigilante crusade. Masuka finds evidence that Cole was killed in his home, which gives further weight to Deb's vigilante theory. LaGuerta points out that a woman would have a hard time overpowering these big guys and Deb says she may have help, from a man. Dexter is there for this talk and looks to be shitting himself. Dex finds out that Quinn checked out the surveillance equipment in his apartment. He also finds out that it's not police business, that Quinn is doing this on his own. Lumen and Dexter search Quinn's apartment and find that he's a fan of cute cat YouTubes. They also find Liddy's photos of them dumping Cole's body into the marina.
HOLY SHIT, Mary Cherry is Dan the Dentist's wife. Deb talks to her and finds out that he would leave for trips with "the guys." The only name she recognizes amongst the teen friend killers is Jordan's. She knows that his real name is Eugene Greer and tells Deb and Quinn. So, they know Jordan was lying about knowing them. Deb tells Dexter that Quinn thought he had something to do with Rita's death.
Dexter tries to get Lumen to leave, but she refuses. Liddy totally tazes Dexter and kidnaps him. Meanwhile, Lumen gets a call from Emily Birch. She says that she was called by Jordan Chase. She wants to go to the police, but Lumen convinces her to wait for her and Dexter. Since she can't get ahold of the kidnapped Dex, she goes by herself. Emily, of course, is calling at Jordan's behest. Liddy tells Quinn to meet him. Lumen gets to Emily's place and Jordan's there. Scary. Liddy tries to force a confession out of Dex, but there's a struggle and Dex kills him, JUST as Quinn is walking to the van. Quinn doesn't uncover the scene, but Liddy's blood drips out of the van onto Quinn's boot.
Then, Dex gets Lumen's message that she's going to Emily's. He tosses Liddy's computer into the water then books it. I can't see why Lumen doesn't just take out Jordan by herself. I feel like she could. Then, she tries to escape and he throws her to the ground. Emily gets upset, so he kills her. Dexter arrives to find blood everywhere. But, it's just Emily's. Lumen and Jordan are nowhere to be found. Deb gets a court order to keep Jordan from leaving on his private jet, but Jordan doesn't show up at the airport. Dexter follows a trail outside of the house. He also finds Lumen's knife. Without saying much, even in VO, you can tell that Dexter is getting pissed. Somebody's getting cut.
Previously: Dexter and Lumen met Emily Birch, who revealed that Jordan Chase had been Eugene Greer. She had been attacked by the guys 20 years earlier. She apparently also loves summers in Stockholm, as she is still under the spell of Jorgene. Quinn told Liddy to stay away from Deb, but she still found out that Quinn had been investigating Dexter. Liddy planted surveillance equipment in Dexter's apartment. Jorgene put in a call to Deb and Quinn leading them to Alex Tilden's house, just as Dexter and Lumen were killing him. They didn't find a body, but they found a footprint, giving further weight to Deb's amazingly spot-on theory of the vigilante killer. Dexter and Lumen made love.
Deb and Quinn visit Jorgene's office. Things are tensely cordial, which I don't imagine will last very long. Deb thanks him for his call about Alex Tilden. She says that they followed up right away, but Alex wasn't there. In fact, it looks like he has disappeared from the face of the earth. Like, Cole. And Boyd, Quinn adds. Oh, you see, I knew something was up here. Deb says that she's been bumping her noggin trying to think of what the connection could be amongst the three missing guys and... she's got it! It's Jordan. He's the connection. She asks that he save her a lot of time and just tell her what that connection is. Jordan covers his face with his hands like he... is... so tired of all of this. So much acting on top of acting in that room. I feel like Quinn should start juggling or something. Jordan says with an incredulous smile that it is ridiculous that she would think that he has anything to do with this. He reminds her that he submitted to a DNA test and he was cleared physically from the Barrel Girls case, so this is a waste of his time. Deb says that she's got tons of time, so she'll just wait for him to give them some information. Then, the scene becomes a Caryl Churchill play and they're talking over each other. He says that she's obsessed with him, which really isn't so odd because he's successful and that sort of thing happens, but it's not healthy for her to be fixated on him instead of her own bleak existence and he can help her. She says that she thinks he slipped up and one of the Barrel Girls got away and is killing the people near him. He could be next. It truly is remarkable how exactly right her theory is. He says that he'll be fine, but he's worried about her. She smiles and leaves with Quinn. His cocky smirk wanes just a little bit as they leave.