Dexter finds Liddy in the station. He says that he's leaving a note for Quinn. Then, he forges Quinn's signature and checks out some surveillance equipment. Dex gets a phone call from Lumen and goes outside to meet her. She says that Emily never told anyone because her father disapproved of her and would have blamed her. Even though she was a camp counselor? Weak. Dexter thinks the mean dad is why Jordan let her live. Well, THAT'S solved. Lumen says that Jordan became a monster when he tortured Emily, but Dex says he already was one. He reminds her that she was supposed to stay in the apartment, but she says she couldn't. He snaps that it's not safe and things get uncomfortably quiet. He asks her if she got the name of the fifth person and she says that she wants to be the one to kill him. Dex says it will change her, but she says she's already changed.

Deb and Quinn sit down with Alex Tilden, at his desk at a bank. He says that he knows Cole from a fantasy football league. He also says that he doesn't know Jordan. Mmhmm. Lumen and Dexter get ready to take out Alex. Dex buys Lumen some black gloves, which she loves. They are pretty cool. Meanwhile, Liddy is listening in on their conversation. In Alex's place, they find a box of jewelry, including a necklace that belonged to Lumen. She takes it back. Lumen goes looking for a kill room.

Jordan is at Emily's place. She tells him that she told Lumen and Dexter everything. She asks if he's in trouble. He says that a girl was making waves, but everything is fine now. Sometimes, I get this weird feeling like Lumen's role with Jordan and company was different before she was their victim. Emily says that Lumen was pretty and he gets all weird and says that no one could ever take her place and that they share an unbreakable bond. He says she made him what he is today. She approaches him and touches his hand, but he pushes it away.