Carol and Ed go into a back room. Carol asks what's wrong with Ed; he denies that anything is wrong. Ed finally admits that Molly told him about Carol and Jackass. Carol guiltily says that she doesn't know what's going on with Jackass, even though they kissed. Ed doesn't need to know details. He's more upset that Carol lied about it to him with no hesitation. Carol apologizes again. Ed walks away all passive-aggressive.
Ed walks back up to Big Pussy as Squeeze's "Tempted" plays on the jukebox. Ed suggests that they go home. Big Pussy spots a lady named Jamie Brown, whom he knows from his business dealings. They flirt. Ed keeps trying to get Big Pussy to leave. Jamie asks Big Pussy to dance. Ed sighs and says that it's trouble. Later, Jamie and Big Pussy walk home with their arms around each other, and flirt some more. Ed follows behind. Big Pussy sends Jamie ahead to the lobby. He turns and tells Ed that he can take it from here. Ed asks him not to do it. Big Pussy says that he's going to do it. Ed wonders why he wants to ruin his marriage. Big Pussy says that there is "not another woman on the planet who can put the slightest dent in [his] feelings for Kay." Big Pussy claims that Kay is his best friend, and she wants him to have this. Then he walks into the hotel to do another babe.
The next morning, Ed walks into the bowling alley to find Phil and Kenny about to unveil their latest creation. There are actual crowds lined up to see it. Kenny hands Ed a plate of chicken wings. Ed says that they're just Buffalo wings, but Phil claims that they are Stuckeyville wings. Big Pussy walks up and asks to talk to Ed.
The two men go into Ed's office and stare at each other for a few minutes. Finally, Ed chuckles and says that Big Pussy couldn't do it. Ed's all happy, until Big Pussy reveals that he did, in fact, do it. Ed doesn't want to believe it. Big Pussy says that it was great. Ed still doesn't want to believe it. Big Pussy doesn't think that they should tell Kay, because it will only hurt her. Ed reminds him that telling her is part of the deal. Big Pussy thinks that if Kay hears that he couldn't go through with it, it will make her happy. Ed has been saying that all along. Big Pussy thinks that they are in agreement. Ed made a promise. Big Pussy wants Ed to think about Kay. Ed is conflicted. You can tell by his sighs.