Warren and Mark sneak down the hallway toward a locker. Warren is carrying roses, and he says that there is "a small window of opportunity." He opens the locker, which belongs to Jessica, and says that this is the perfect plan because it has both surprise and romance. Mark stuffs Warren into the locker and shuts the door. Mark walks off just as Jessica turns the corner. Mark whispers to Warren that Jessica is on her way. Jessica walks by her locker, looks into her bag, and then keeps walking. Warren starts calling out to her and banging on the locker. He starts screaming at her to open the locker quickly. She does, and Warren falls out onto the floor, gasping for air. Jessica asks why he was hiding in her locker. Warren wheezes that he wanted to apologize for messing up their date, and adds that he brought her roses. Jessica is charmed. She tells Warren that her parents are going out of town, and she's having a party. Warren asks if he's invited, and Jessica says that he is. Warren tries to pretend he didn't just make a fool of himself.

Molly teaches the night class. Phil's cell phone rings, and he loudly begins a conversation with someone named Enrique about buying something. Molly tries to reprimand him, but Phil isn't listening. Molly dismisses the class. Phil compliments Molly's teaching. Molly says that this isn't going to work. Phil asks how it is going to work, because he's already shown up a few times and everyone has seen his face. Molly says that she's not giving Phil a diploma, and stomps off. Phil can't believe it. Molly tells him that in order to get a diploma, Phil will have to pass the course like everyone else. Phil says that this has been a very educational night, and stomps out. Jim walks in and asks if Phil is not quite the model student. Molly agrees. Jim suggests "a one-two punch of pizza and beer with Mr. Friendly Face." He makes a goofy smiling face and holds it. Molly chuckles and says she'll do it if he promises to hold that face for the whole night. Jim agrees, and then says that his cheeks are already cramping.