Welcome to WeepFest 2006! Our beloved, cheesy, awesome show is over, y'all. So, Nina's getting ready to leave her house -- which has already sold -- and move to L.A. with Dimples. The packing is interrupted when she confesses to Hannah that Treat bought her an engagement ring. Hannah is all over it, and talks Nina into sneaking into the Browns' house to look at the ring. Wackiness ensues when Treat comes home; Nina sneaks out unseen, but Hannah somehow ends up with the ring in her possession. Of course, Dimples McGee finds the ring in Hannah's room, gets the story from Nina (who is at her ineffectual worst), then confronts Treat -- again -- about their dueling affections for Nina. Treat denies that he was planning to do anything while Dimples was still with Nina, but admits he's hoping it won't work out. Everybody has to have a dream.
Delia's birthday and Bat Mitzvah has finally arrived. Delia gives a wonderful speech about her family and her mom, and then becomes a woman. Treat cluelessly invites Ephram's "friend" Stephanie to go with them, and she's nice enough, but no Amy Abbott. Speaking of whom, Our Lady of Sad Bangs realizes she's still in love with Ephram once she gets a glimpse of him and Stephanie dancing it up at the party. This prompts about sixty hours of moping around, talking it out, and trying to decide what to do. Her first step -- telling Stephanie that she still has feelings for Ephram -- backfires spectacularly, so it's back to the drawing board.
Meanwhile, one of Patch Abbott's patients abandons her infant daughter on the Abbotts' doorstep, with a note explaining she won't be coming back. Rose immediately becomes overly attached to the child, and after a half-hearted search for the mother, the Abbotts file for custody of the baby. Patch takes the baby over to Feisty Nurse Edna's for a visit, and finds Edna preparing to hit the road in her RV. She's so grief-stricken that she basically tells Patch she has no more reason to live, now that Irv is gone. Rose and Patch awesomely decide to fix up a room in their house for her, and amidst all kinds of tears, Edna decides to stay.
And now, the wrap-up: Hannah is trying to decide whether to stay in Everwood and go to A&M, or head on over to Notre Dame, where she has a full scholarship. It is Bright's totally unselfish suggestion that she go to Notre Dame that makes her decide to stay in Everwood. Dimples and Nina leave for L.A., but at the airport, Dimples tells her he can't be with someone whose heart is still with someone else. After a tearful goodbye, Nina ends up back at Treat's house, as hers is already sold. Treat decides to propose, but has to do something first: he flies to New York and visits Julia's grave to say goodbye one last time, then flies back to Everwood and asks Nina to marry him in one of the greatest proposals ever. Nina accepts, of course.
Amy has finally thought of a way to announce her love to Ephram. She enlists Rose's help in setting up the Thaw Fest ferris wheel right outside the Brown house. When Ephram walks outside to leave for his date with Stephanie, Amy is there waiting. She tells him how she feels, they kiss, and it is perfect.
Wait, one more thing: Delia gets her horse!
PS: Damn you, Berlanti.
Previously on Everwood: The entire fourth season. Oh, how I've missed this show. Also, Ephram's trying to move on by dating a girl named Stephanie; Dimples and Nina are moving to Los Angeles; Treat has bought an engagement ring to not give to Nina; Irv has died; and Patch Abbott has recently had a pregnant schizophrenic patient with a dying husband.
We open at the Brown House, which I'm sad to say immediately moves me to tears. I'm so sorry y'all got stuck with such a sentimental mess of a recapper for three sopping wet seasons. It's going to be a long, moist night. Anyway, Treat, Ephram, Delia, and Ephram's new girl Stephanie are cleaning up after dinner. Hellooooo, Ephram Brown. Long time, nice haircut. Delia tells Stephanie about all the things she's learned for her Bat Mitzvah, including how cute her Rabbi is. Stephanie looks like what Fergie would if she hadn't plasticized herself to hideous and back. She tells Delia that that always helps -- she once had a physics professor who looked like Johnny Depp. Ephram interjects, "You know, I've been told that I have a Depp-like quality." Hee. Stephergie tells him he's been lied to. Delia's all excited because her Bat Mitzvah is at the Carousel Building at the fairgrounds. Stephergie thinks that sounds like one rockin' party. Ephram: "I think that's how they phrased it in the Torah." Ephram's copy of the Torah is obviously the expurgated version, penned by the Black Eyed Peas. It also says that if Jesus had existed he would have shaken it like a Poloroid picture. Delia's all, "Oh my God, you should come! Can she?" Treat says it's not that simple, that this thing is like a wedding, with rented tables and assigned seating and things like that, like, way to be totally rude in front of your guest, Treat. Delia argues that now that Dimples, Nina, and Sam aren't coming, there's room for Stephergie. Treat realizes what an ass he's being, and tells Stephergie he'd be delighted if she came, and actually insists that she be there. Ephram asks Stephergie if she even wants to come, and she says it sounds like fun. Ephram: "Yeah, what could be more fun than a lot of Hebrew and a bunch of bratty 13-year-olds?" I can think of several things that involve you and your new haircut, Ephram Brown. My God, I've become a pedophile again. Suddenly, Treat storms out of the room with a trash bag. Stephergie asks if everything's okay, and she really doesn't have to go; Ephram says it's fine, it's not her, and goes out to see what his dramatic Daddy's problem is.