Felicity and Knoll are leaving the apartment to go study at the library all night, and she's worried about Ben's staying in the apartment with Molly, in case James comes back. Ben insists he'll be fine. Felicity tells him that she was really proud of the way he handled James. Ben admits that he was trying not to wet his pants at the time. He wishes her luck on the final and she leaves. He looks in on Molly, who is sleeping.

At the library, Felicity is ready to give up because she's exhausted and barely coherent. Knoll pushes her to continue studying because he has "faith" that she can do anything she wants, and he has felt like that ever since he met her. Then he tells her to focus because he's there "sacrificing what little time [he has] to study for [his] own finals," and not everyone would benefit from his largesse. He wants "this to be one of those nights [they] look back on when [they're] old," so that they can reminisce about the "all-nighter" they pulled. There he goes again, presuming that Felicity will even want to acknowledge his existence in years to come. He says that she's saving his ass with Stupid Cartoon Premise and he's going to save hers "with Western Thought." Felicity rallies and says, "Let's do it."

Ben is asleep on the sofa when Molly comes out, wrapped in a blanket. She tells Ben that she needs to break up with James, and that she has to do it in person. Ben cautions her against seeing James again, but she maintains that James would never hurt her. Ben thinks she should do it in a public place; he says he'll go with her, but stay out of the way.