The title tells us that it is now 5:15 PM and they have been underground for three and a half hours. Felicity is telling Sally that she doesn't know if it was "cabin fever, lack of oxygen, or if they were stuck with the strangest strangers of all time, but it became a free-for-all." We see all the passengers discussing Julie and Felicity's case. Annoying Vendor Guy asks who Ben is again, and everyone groans and yells at him. Young Hip Guy says that Julie knew that Felicity liked Ben for years. Julie says, "So?" and Young Hip Guy says that it shouldn't have been a surprise that she went with him. Ditzy Blonde Lady says (kind of out of nowhere) that her friends before college are still her friends today. Julie says it's not like that for her because she had a lot of boyfriends in high school, but no girl friends. Creepy Greasy Guy speaks up and says that Julie was a sex toy. Julie gets all offended and he says that he's not passing judgment. He's dated women like her, and "I applaud you, baby." Julie says that Felicity was her first real best friend so she was surprised that she did what she did. Everyone murmurs agreement. Felicity says that not only did she not have any girl friends in high school, she didn't have a boyfriend either. Loser! Ha, I'm just kidding.
Angry Bald Guy asks why they're traveling together if they hate each other. They say they're not - they just both happened to be there. Felicity says she was going to the museum, and Julie says that she was too. Why did she have her guitar with her then? Or does she just use her guitar case as a purse? Wise Older Lady says that they were meant to be on the same train, and the two of them are the reason the train stopped. Angry Black Guy says, "Tell that to the dead guy on the tracks." Wise Older Lady says that the rest of the passengers are all meant to help them reunite. Crazy Bald Guy suddenly spots some Mole People and all the passengers rush to the windows. We see a group of about six freaky-looking people walking through the tunnel. As they get closer, we see that one of them is Meghan! I have to say that I didn't see that coming, and I hope the writers follow up on that, because now I'm intrigued.
Ben is leaving Dean and Deluca when Maggie comes in. She says she was setting up her party when it hit her that she was a jerk to him, and that she likes that he spoke up to her. He asks why she isn't getting ready for her party, and she says she wanted to invite him. They exchange meaningful looks, but don't say anything more and she leaves.