Felicity exits the elevator and tiptoes back into the loft, just like in the second episode of the season. FVO says, "Sally, I didn't know if I was going insane, or if this was a dream. To be honest, I still don't." Felicity walks over and finds her bag, then looks confused. Ben walks in carrying a pizza and a basketball. Shouldn't Scott Speedman have a crew cut like he did in the beginning of the season? Bad continuity. Felicity says that she thought he was going to a hotel. Ben is confused, and once he recovers, he apologizes for the incident with the printer, and says that being pre-med has freaked him out. Felicity doesn't know what he's talking about. Ben reminds her of the fight they had, and admits that he was a jerk, but explains that Prof. Snark makes him anxious. Felicity asks if it's a joke, and Ben says again that he's trying to apologize. Noel shows up and lies that he was hanging out on the roof by himself, all alone, not with Felicity at all. Felicity finally realizes that Meghan's spell worked. She says that she needs to go find Meghan, and runs out.
Felicity enters her old dorm. In the hallway, she catches sight of herself in a mirror and notices that her hair is curly again. She runs into Meghan's room, where Meghan is sleeping. Felicity starts babbling that the spell worked. Meghan wonders whether she could do a spell on Felicity to make her shut up. Felicity keeps babbling on and on about the spell and that it took her back to the roof, to the night that she slept with Noel. That gets Meghan's attention. Meghan rolls over, removes her leopard-print sleep mask, and asks, "You slept with Noel?" Felicity repeats that Meghan sent her back in time. Meghan sits up and says, "Okay. That must have been the greatest sex ever, because you've completely lost your mind." Felicity tells Meghan that she came back into town for Noel's wedding. Meghan is more amused than frightened as she tells Felicity that it's "the greatest thing ever" because Felicity has "officially gone insane." Meghan points out the "mammoth hickey" on Felicity's neck.