Taylor freaks out because he is snowed in at his sister's house and thus cannot run the annual winter carnival. The townies agree to let Kirk do it, but then Taylor returns to Stars Hollow incognito to spy on the proceedings, which include Lorelai setting up a booth for Paul Anka to tell fortunes. Logan pours on the gifts and flowers trying to get Rory back -- he even rents out the coffee cart to follow her around. Luke and April have their first father-daughter get-together in the park, and agree to meet next time at the diner, though he later tries to renege out of nervousness about Lorelai, and gets an earful from Anna about his responsibilities as a parent. Paris is having big dramas at the paper, and Rory is caught in the middle when the staff plans a hostile takeover. Logan comes to the Inn to meet with Lorelai to attempt to ask for her help in charming Rory. Conversely, Zach tries to have a showdown with Mrs. Kim, but it's more of a shootdown. At the diner, Lorelai runs into April, who introduces herself as Luke's daughter. Lorelai is rightfully shocked and upset. Rory helps her to gain perspective, explaining that this same thing happened to Gwen Stefani and Gavin Rossdale and that they worked through it. Luke apologizes to Lorelai for being so overwhelmed about everything, but when she volunteers to postpone the wedding, he jumps at it, making her very sad.
The huge emergency is that he is snowed in and will not be able to get back to run the annual Winter Carnival. This announcement is met with yawns. No one can see the problem, and Taylor can't see that they don't care he won't be there. He says they've never had to cancel a carnival, and the crowd goes...blah. They still don't get what he's so het up about. "I won't be there to run the carnival," he says, dramatically. "Draw the obvious conclusions!" Ah, light dawns on Miss Patty. "Kirk," she says, "can you take over?" Kirk says sure, and thus the meeting ends with all of them filing out as Taylor rattles on with his carnival recommendations.
At the diner later, Luke is so tired he's pouring people coffee into their teacups. "Now you've got a hybrid," he tells one customer. "That's very in right now." Lorelai, despite having kept such late hours, is full of vim. She says she saw the sunrise, paid all her bills, and, for the first time ever, saw the beginning of The Today Show. While Luke sleeps on his feet, she rambles on that Katie and Matt are much more serious in the first half-hour than in the second, which she says makes sense, because people can deal with bad news when they first wake up. "But then," she says, "just as they're heading to the office, you leave them with a dose of Matthew McConaughey, People's Sexiest Man and whoosh they're rarin' to go." Luke says that, yes, Matthew McConaughey always gets him rarin', and the fan-fic just writes itself. Lorelai goes on that she's even volunteered to have a booth at the carnival this year and that she has her concept all worked out. She asks Luke if he has any special plans for later today and he suddenly becomes all goofy, overcompensating for his secret plans with April, Secret Daughter, whom he is visiting later on. He leaves her with a kiss as the guy with the hybrid coffee-tea (Cofftea? Don't bother, I just trademarked it.) announces that he's not loving it too much.In her scary stairwell, Rory sighs and picks up what appears to be yet another bouquet of flowers from the reptile Logan. They are beautiful flowers, and the dozens of bouquets inside are beautiful as well. Paris is less than pleased, saying that the criminal element surrounding the apartment might see all the flowers and gifts and think they're rich. "They scream bling," Paris says. "Bad guys see roses, then they come for our diamonds." Rory reminds her that they do not have diamonds. "The doo-wop group doesn't know that," Paris retorts, and tells her to put these latest flowers by the neon sign that says "Come Pistol-Whip Us."