Ted asks what happened. Mickey laughs. "Sorry, Ted. Gall bladder burst! You move back three spaces." It is then that Marshall finally loses his patience. "You come in here, and you watch your daughter leave and you don't even care. And now you've destroyed Thanksgiving dinner! Lily -- Lily worked all day on this!" Mickey tells him to relax. "It's not real bile. It's just lead-based paint from China." Oh, well then -- invite over the neighborhood children. It will toughen them up for the hectic Christmastime toy-chewing rush. Mickey waits a beat. "And horse bile." As Marshall rises from his seat and looms over his father-in-law, Saget!Ted narrates that it was at that moment that Marshall gave Mickey a look they'd never before seen. The Exorcist-y music starts up, and Marshall looks like he's about to hold his breath, but then relaxes his face. Mickey asks the gang what he's doing. Ted asks Marshall, "Did you swallow some of that paint?" Marshall explains that that was his you're-dead-to-me-look. The gang tries to mumble supportively. Mickey says Lily's is much better. Marshall screams, "Get out of my house!" and we sideways slide to...

The bodega downstairs: Marshall finds Lily seated at the counter and says it's the last place he would have expected her to be (as Mr. Park was one of the aforementioned Dark Willow victims). He apologizes and says he's learned that family isn't a right, but a privilege. He said he kicked out Mickey and he'll never make her see him again. Lily spins towards him and cries. When Marshall asks her what's wrong, it all comes pouring out. "Marshall, I came in here because it was cold and this was the only place that was open. I wasn't even gonna look Mr. Park in the eye. And then I found out...Mr. Park died." When someone who was dead-to-her turned up dead to her, Lily felt awful and she realized that since she feels so bad about not making up with Mr. Park, "A guy who meant literally nothing to me..." Her confession is interrupted by the horrified and heartbroken sobs of a woman I assume is Mrs. Park, who scurries out of sight. Lily continues: "We've gotta go get my dad." Marshall takes his coat off to wrap it around Lily and we cut to...