She walks off to cool her heels, giving Ronnie the opportunity to go outside and talk it over with the housemates. Sitch tells Ronnie he heard rumors that Sammi very likely hooked up with the text-message lothario. JWOWW pragmatically suggests SamRo 2.0 call it even considering his (actual) indiscretions in Miami. Pauly and Ronnie both insist this summer in Jersey was supposed to start with a clean slate. Pauly adds that Sammi won't admit to what she did, which is off-base on multiple levels, including the fact that Ronnie only admitted his bullshit after being forced to and also the fact that there is no proof that Sammi actually did anything wrong. Not to mention the fact that they were broken up (albeit for about 36 hours) at the time of the supposed text affair. Ugh. It's too stupid to parse any further. But I'm sure they will for the rest of the unholy lives, even after the damn cameras leave. Vinny likewise goads Ronnie's insecurities. JWOWW says she thinks the guys are brainwashing Ronnie. To wit, Ronnie insists it only looks like The Situation is stirring the pot when, in fact, he's being a true friend. Unlike those note-writing hussies in Miami. It just goes to show for the bazillionth time that the loudest person at the Jersey Shore is the right one. Argh.
Inside, JWOWW fills in Sammi about the trash Sitch is talking. Sammi bursts outside, and the guys clam up. She calls Sitch a scheming, shady scumbag. Sitch sticks to his story and there's lots of overlapping screaming that ends with Sitch telling Sammi she's a bad arguer. Fair enough. Her main point does seem to be "You're a liar," though she can't prove irrefutably that she didn't do anything wrong. Then again, how do you prove the absence of something? She insists she has nothing to hide, so Ronnie tells Sitch to find Arvin's phone number so they can have a little conference call. And they call Sammi a sneaky bitch. A lot.
The guys head inside, where Vinny basically says he wouldn't trust a girl to text another guy about anything, even the weather. All the guys agree heartily, which pretty neatly sums up the unwinnable mindset Sammi is up against. Pauly calls shenanigans that Sammi was good friends with this guy and Ronnie had never heard of him. Because, as we know, all girlfriends must report to their abusive, 'roided out boyfriends before they even consider breathing.