Now it's time for the after party at a club called Señor Frog's a.k.a. Overpriced Tourist Trap. Everyone dances. Anthony voice-overs that he didn't just lose the Switch Card, he lost his partner. The Sad Piano Music of Anthony Getting His Just Deserts plays as we see Tony and Laura on a bus, headed back to the boat. They arrive at the boat alone, and strip down to their underwear. The others arrive back at the boat. Toni voice-overs that something is up, and she knows that Anthony can feel it, because they all can see it. In Laura's cabin, Tony gives Laura a foot massage, and offers a back massage. As everyone boards the boat, Toni voice-overs that there is a lot of tension, and that something is definitely going to happen. Meanwhile, Tony rubs Laura's back, if you include the ass as part of the back. Lisa enters her cabin to find Tony gone. We don't get to see what happens when Anthony returns to his cabin. What a rip-off. Instead, Anthony says in The Booth that he would like to turn Laura off as easily as he can turn off the camera. Whatever, Anthony.

Day Five. At breakfast, Anthony does spin control to Lisa and Jeanette. Anthony claims that Laura wants to get her freak on, and that he told her not to hook up with him if that was the case. And yet, Anthony claims, Laura was the aggressive one in their relationship. In an interview, Anthony thinks that Laura's relationship with Tony isn't right, and that it might blow up in her face.

Up on deck, Laura and Toni lie on towels and chat. Toni says that no one is doing anything that bad, because there are no relationships or commitments. Laura agrees, and says she would like to see what happens with Tony. Toni cautions her that Lisa might also like Tony, and that Laura should respect that. Laura confides that she thinks Lisa likes Anthony. Toni agrees, and points out that Anthony even said that Lisa was his type.

The captain announces that it's time for the Gender Juries. In an interview, Adrian says that he can't wait to talk about whom to vote off the ship, but he's worried that as the holder of the Switch Card, he may have to get rid of someone the women like. The men and women both get things sorted out. The last shot is of Anthony. He is wearing a red polka-dotted shirt, and a red bandanna on his head. If he only added an upside-down visor, he would be Anthony Boogie.

Anthony tells the men that he wants to vote off Laura because he feels that he got slammed, and it messed him up. Tony wants to vote off Jeanette, because she made a comment about Adrian looking at her. Wow, that's a good reason. Not.