Andrea drama-queens for a few minutes before cryptically saying, "It's not the same for both of you. The feelings." Oh, just come right out and say what you have to say. First of all, Lisa should have gone to Toni first. And second of all, Andrea is enjoying this moment way too much. And third of all, these people have known each other a week. Seven days. They act like they're breaking up a marriage on the silver anniversary or something. Toni gets upset and runs away, and Andrea chases after her. Toni fumes that she's not going to date anymore, because this always happens. Andrea tells Toni to trust herself, and reminds her that Anthony called the ship "the S.S. Rumor." Toni cries and says this always happens to her. Andrea comforts Toni, but pushes Toni's head down on her shoulder so that the camera will get the best angle.
So what would be the logical thing to do next? Toni should talk to Greg, right? Michael recaps for us that if Andrea, Jeanette, or Adrian got voted off, he probably wouldn't use his switch card. Tomiko doesn't think that Adrian will get voted off. In an interview, Toni says that Lisa told Andrea that Greg was hitting on her, and now Toni doesn't know how to vote. Maybe she could ask Greg if Lisa is being truthful? Just a thought. But, no. It's time for the Gender Juries to convene.
The men gather. Anthony says that he's voting for Jeanette because Adrian is his boy, and they've all "formed a pretty strong brotherhood." I wonder what's going to happen to that brotherhood in a few days when they need to start backstabbing each other as their numbers dwindle. Adrian makes a speech about Jeanette not apologizing, but instead claiming that she didn't say he was a deadbeat dad. So he's voting for Jeanette. Well, I'm glad her speech got through to him.
Jeanette tells the women that she's not as vehement that Adrian needs to leave as she was last time around. Greg says that he narrowed it down to Jeanette and Andrea. Jeanette has been out of line, so he casts his vote for Jeanette. He also thinks he needs to give Andrea another chance.
Lisa holds her hat onto her head, like, just take it off or put your hair in a ponytail or something. God, she's annoying. Lisa tells the other women that she "heard something yesterday that made [her] think that [Greg] may not have the same depth of feeling as [Toni]." Lisa admits that Greg gave her these huge compliments. And she wasn't fishing for them at all. Actually, she was fishing for them so hard that she was practically holding a rod and reel. Lisa wonders whether Greg was complimenting the other women, too. No one really says that he was. Andrea pipes up that she's been wondering who is fake and who is genuine. I'll give her a hint. None of them on that ship are genuine. That should make it easier for her. Toni says that she'll go along with whatever the other women decide. The other women all agree to vote for Greg, and Toni goes along with it. Over on the men's side, Greg tells the men that he's really into Toni, and that he misjudged her on the first day. Aw. Poor Bug-Eye's one chance at love, and those harpies stole it away from her because of stupid Lisa and her stupid rumors. Toni thinks it would "blow their mind" if she announced the vote.