Hanna and Mona are being catty about the other girls. Lucas comes over to take pictures of them for yearbook. Mona dismisses him, and Hanna is actually polite to him. By which I mean she treats him like a human being. Mona doesn't understand why Hanna would talk to herme (short for hermaphrodite), but Hanna claims he's a decent enough guy. Mona thinks that talking to him will ruin their social standing. Mona's not going to be dragged down by Hanna. Hanna responds to this by eating a little piece of cake.

Aria finally arrives at the bean bag toss, and who should be the faculty person there but Mr. Fitz. Naturally. Melissa saunters over to Spencer and asks Alex if he's on the homecoming committee, and Spencer has to explain that he goes to a public school across town. Someone comes up with a catering crisis, and Spencer grabs Alex and runs away before Melissa can fuck things up. Aria's head pops up in one of the heart shaped cutouts, and she tries to convince Fitz to believe that she didn't plan this. He doesn't really buy it. She compliments his haircut. Oh, did I mention that Aria's wearing one teeny-tiny little glove? After the customers walk away, she tries again to tell him that she didn't tell anyone, but that "A" is someone who is messing with her. He doesn't understand why, and she starts to tell him, but can't really give him an answer. A teacher comes over to relieve Aria, and she jumps at the chance to leave.

Toby and Emily walk up to the dance. She looks smoking hot wearing an electric blue knee length dress that is simple, with just a little bit of fringe at the bottom and she looks very sexy with her hair down and curly. He offers to take her to a Fritz Lang film fest instead, but she claims she's overdressed. He reveals that he's never been to a school dance before, and is nervous about meeting her friends who already seem predisposed to hate him. Aria walks back to Hanna and Spencer, and says she got claustrophobic and hopes they can find someone to replace her. Spence says that every freshman girl will jump at the chance to spend time alone with Fitz. Maya pops up excited to see Hanna, and she's looking for Emily. But Aria gets a panicked look on her face when she sees that Emily just walked in with Toby.

When the couple walks over, the girls aren't exactly welcoming to her. They all think she's sleeping with the enemy, and that he has to be the one helping Jenna. She insists that they don't know him. Emily is especially annoyed with Hanna, who gets in some vindictive cracks, and says she was the one who told her to follow her feelings in the first place. Hanna thought that was because she thought she was taking Maya... Emily doesn't understand why Hanna would think that.