There's a car that can be won, and Alex is staring at it. Melissa asks if he bought a raffle ticket and wonders where Spencer is. She tells him he's being used to piss off Spencer's father. The girls all wonder when Toby and Emily started hanging out, but their dates all come over to whisk them away to dance before they can truly suss out this great mystery. Aria ends up dancing with some unfamiliar guy, who may or may not be the aforementioned Chris.
Maya is dancing with another unfamiliar guy while the band plays some sensitive music, and we see all of the different couples enjoying their slow dance. Spencer in particular looks happy to be with Alex, until she gets some sort of spark of inspiration and grabs the girls. She says she's figured out that Toby's tattoo means September 1st. The day that Ali disappeared. They say that Emily won't believe them without the file and they send the soon-to-be crowned homecoming queen to go across town in her dress to get Jenna's information from the office. Hanna begs Aria to keep Sean occupied in the meantime.
Alex tries to get Spencer to go to the fortune teller, but she says that it's not really her scene. Then changes her mind. Aria does a shitty job of lying to Sean but distracts him with food. Hanna requests a cab, and Lucas overhears her. He wants to know why the homecoming queen would leave and compares it to Han Solo leaving the Millennium Falcon. This goes over Hanna's really large hair. He's leaving because he got his yearbook pictures, and she wants to know if he just came for the sole purpose of picture taking. He says he came for that and to vote for her. Aw. Sweet. She says she left the check for the band where she works and begs a ride from him. He says this is a better option than Hoarders. I'm not so sure about that.
Spencer's fortune reveals that she's anxiety ridden. Spencer can't stop watching Emily, but her ears perk up when the fortune teller says that Spencer will be taking care of someone who has been hurt. Sean gripes about being ditched, and Aria makes him "bump and grind" with her. Nope, didn't need that image. Maya, who is rockin' a Bump-It, sees Emily and glares. She leaves Toby alone for a second and he sees that Jenna is there just sitting on a bench. Emily wants to know what Maya told Hanna, and Maya says Hanna approached her. Maya says she should go back to her date since she's clearly moved on. Emily just wants more time, and Maya says she's giving her space to come to grips with who she is, not to hide it. She wants her to look her in the eye and tell her that she doesn't have feelings for her. Em can't do it.