When the judges start deliberating, Heidi says, "Let's start with Bradley Baumkirchner." Now, if any of you have this on TiVo or DVR, go back and listen to her say that. She's a crazy warrior. Hormones? Who can say for sure. All I know is it scares me. And I like it. All of the judges love his outfit for its originality.
The judges like Uli's dress a lot, and the outfit that she made for her dog. Ivanka thinks that, above all of the designers, Alison really had a complete look. Vera liked Katie's doggy hoodie, but nothing else. Nina says there was a lack of originality there. About Angela, Nina says, "I. Did. Not. Really. Like. This. At. All." Me. Neither. Ivanka thinks that Angela's model looked like a streetwalker. Ivanka also did not like Keith's attitude. Girl has been watching her reality TV too, because she suggests watching footage of the workroom to see if Keith really made "many, many outfits for the dog." Otherwise, everyone liked the dress.
The judges have decided, and they bring the designers back out. Uli is the winner of the challenge. I personally liked Alison's better, but Uli's was great. Also, she honestly seems like a really sweet lady. Uli interviews that she was surprised. Next, Alison is "in." She seems upset. Bradley is "in!" Yay! He seems really relieved. Keith is "in." Heidi says that he might have won, had he designed an outfit for his dog. Keith interviews that it doesn't make sense that he didn't win. Argh. So, it doesn't make sense that they asked you to do something and you just didn't do it -- and you didn't win? He adds that there was no "good execution on the stage" except for his, which is total bullshit and so stupid. Isn't all this a little too much trouble to go to for not wanting to make a fucking puppy sweater? You stupid, stupid man.
It's down to Katie and Angela. Heidi says that Katie's outfit was poorly executed and uninspired. She says that Angela's outfit was well constructed but over the top. And, snap, they question her taste level. I knew it was coming some time. Angela is... "in." For real? Her construction was good enough to forgive that monstrosity? Wow.
Katie says that she was shocked to be auf'd. She gets hugs from everyone backstage. She says that she still likes what she made. When she's cleaning up her workspace, she writes a note that reads: "I had a blast. Miss you all! Good luck." She concludes that it's best to go home with a design that you liked. I guess.