And speaking of... That night at the bar, Sam offers Andi a shot to ease her news given what he's about to tell her. She refuses, so Sam takes it himself. JBL is there, too, and basically tramples all over Sam's attempt at a delicate confession. He spits out Sam's extracurricular entanglements matter-of-factly, and Sam confirms. Now we see that Ben's there, too. Jesus, Sam...what a wimp. Andi walks off, stopping to tell Sam she is completely unconvinced. Sam gets mad at JBL and Ben for not helping more, but they were preoccupied by chili cheese fries and a wife, respectively. Sam leaves to reap King.
Sam creeps into King's office, scythe in hand, and discovers a back office filled with photos of King and his hundreds of babies, a calendar of upcoming birth dates, and a (thankfully) incomplete nude self-portrait. WiseGuy interrupts Sam's reconnaissance work to malign Sam for being distracted by Andi. He threatens to handle it himself. Elsewhere, Andi is about to make the call to the police...until someone grabs her. Her phone drops to the ground. Commercials.
Back at The Bench, Sam leaves a frantic message for Andi. JBL and Ben try to assure him that Andi's not in danger, saying they took care of it. They lead him outside to a parked car, where Andi is bound and gagged in the trunk. Sam asks what their plan is...but they haven't really thought that far ahead. So Sam, bearing that ultimate "We're sorry we abducted you" gift -- a juice box -- goes to the back seat to have a chat with Andi. She says she believes him about the Devil thing, but he knows she's lying. She relents and accepts the apple juice, but when Sam tries to give it to her, she attacks him. JBL and Ben chat outside the car, which prevents them from seeing Sam's struggle for a several moments. At last, they rescue Sam, but not before Andi threatens to kill them all. Sam decides that they need to scare Andi into believing them.
The Stooges drive up to Tony's cottage as a procession of demons leaves. Tony worries WiseGuy followed them, but Sam tells Tony they're not there for the rebellion, and instead have another problem... Cut to the three of them struggling to get Andi inside. Sam tells her Tony is a demon, and Tony warns them (JBL specifically, it seems) not to pee on the new carpet, before transforming into his demon form. Once he's fully demonized, a terrified Andi makes tracks for the woods. Tony assures The Stooges she has nowhere to run...that is, until they hear the car engine fire up and realize JBL, in his infinite wisdom, left the keys in the car.