Back at The Bench, Sam recounts what just happened. He pulls out the vessel box and opens it…behold! It's a Fair Isle sweater adorned with a snowman and snowwoman. Ben asks if it's the Devil who gave it to Sam, or his grandmother. JBL pipes in that maybe Sam will wear it, and the soul will laugh himself back to Hell. Unfazed by their joshing, Sam says they should head back to the sewer.
Sam's dad interrupts them to return Sam's wallet, which fell out of his pocket during an STW-related incident. As Sam closes his locker, Dad notices the contract. Sam swiftly shuts the locker. Dad offers to look through the contract, but Sam says no. They walk out, and Dad admits that the contract brought back feelings of guilt. He says he wants to meet with the Devil to arrange a barter. He can trade his soul for Sam's by putting to use his devilishly good advertising skills, such as creating cartoon mascots to sell cigarettes to kids. Sam reluctantly agrees.
As Sam walks out, he passes Andi, who has received a gorgeous bouquet of lilies. Tedager walks up to castigate Sam for interoffice romancing, but Sam clarifies that he didn't send them. Andi states the obvious -- they're from Greg. Tedager heartily approves since he once had a conversation with Greg about ceiling fans. Sam says the lilies are nice, and Andi comes back that his sweater is a real sexy number. She asks where Sam's headed. He vagues an obvious lie, sparking her annoyance. He admits that he hasn't been 100 percent honest with her and says that he has some things to tell her. They make a date to talk it out that evening -- and I, for one, am positive he'll make it there, and right on time, nay early! (Sarcasm.) Sam walks out, but only after taking a header at the door.
The Stooges arrive at the crash site, outfitted in Wellies. They pop open the manhole and reel back at its stank aroma. Luckily, Ben has some strawberry lip balm with which they can coat their nostrils. As they navigate the underground, Sam says he plans to come clean with Andi. JBL points out that the truth might make Andi think Sam's crazy, but Sam counters that she probably already does.
Their girl talk is interrupted when Ben spots a trail of slime a few yards ahead. Sam follows the trail through a drainpipe and ends up outside an estate, where a political fundraiser for City Council hopeful Bobby Hartford is taking place. JBL immediately zeroes in on the open bar, but they're quickly intercepted by Hartford himself. Security rolls up to handle the situation, and Sam tries to cover by saying they knew Ed Fazio. Wrong move. Upon hearing Fazio's name Hartford threatens to call the police. Sam tells Hartford that Fazio died a few hours before, but Hartford just smirks and calls a goon over to escort The Stooges out.