Exhausted, Ems and Dan get to Casa Emily. Emanda is greeted immediately by Sammy. Sounding like a robot, Daniel suggests she take the dog for a walk. Ems briefly stops in her tracks in the foreground of the shot, registering the steeliness of Dan's voice. She carefully says she was planning on doing just that after she changes clothes. When she leaves the room, Dan starts scanning the floorboards for a secret compartment.

Jack gets back to a dark Porter bar. He notices blood on his sleeve and starts to take off his hoodie. He's startled to find Dec sitting in the dark, waiting for him in Jack's bedroom. Dec immediately asks where his brother's been, or better yet, why he's not in Haiti. Jack says his boat engine crapped out. The thing about that is Dec saw the boat in the dock an hour ago. So where's Jack been since then? Jack ignores Dec's question and turns it back around to ask what Declan's doing awake. It's been a crazy night Dec says, adding that Tyler was murdered. Jack's voice goes up an octave when he asks, "Tyler?" Dec says Charlotte told cops they saw a guy in a hoodie. Shits! Jack's holding a hoodie! Trying to act as natural as possible, Jack starts asking questions a concerned brother should be asking. Is Dec all right? What happened? There's definitely a tone in Dec's voice that he senses something's off while he talks to Jack. He slowly gets closer to his brother and spots Jack's terrible job of hiding his hoodie on his chair, but doesn't say anything. He just says he didn't get a good look at the hoodied figure's face, and he's going to bed.

Casa Emily. Ems comes back home to find Dan searching through a box he found in the floorboards. It's pretty obvious right away that it's not the infinity x infinity box. It looks more like a tackle box. He asks Emanda what it is. Ems plays dumb, saying it must be there from the previous owner. Dan, probably feeling a little dumb, tells his fiancé he was foolishly searching for secrets Tyler told him were hidden under Emanda's floorboards. Ems comforts Dan, saying Tyler was crazy and a liar. She brushes off an apology from Daniel because she figures he must be traumatized and injured. It's all cliché girlfriend stuff from here. She loves him and will stay by his side no matter what. They get up to go to bed. Ems take a glance at the fake infinity x infinity box over her shoulder as they walk off together.