Back in the present, Henry tells Shiv it was an accident. He didn't tell her because after learning she was screwing Tyler, he couldn't trust her. Shiv meekly takes the blame and apologizes for getting him mixed up in everything. She says since they now have the flash drive, it should all be over soon, but Henry confesses he gave it to Tim Arbogast as proof he should pull his investment.
Andrew's home from the hospital wearing a sling on his right arm, but since he's sure Olivia took the kid, he's blaming himself for her disappearance. If he hadn't agreed to the Ponzi scheme, he'd still have his girl at home. Bridget tells him to stop. All that matters is finding Juliet and they will. She can't figure out what Olivia would want with Juliet. Andrew says all he can figure is that Olivia is going to use Juliet to blackmail Andrew into shouldering all the blame for the scheme.
Bridget: Wouldn't Olivia contact you to let you know what she wants?
Andrew: I'd think so. Where could she be hiding Juliet?
Recapper: In her crypt?
Buffy: No, Cindy. While Olivia is a vampire, she did not grab Juliet. Remember the kid was packing woolens for Miami. She took off. Nice Me is going to figure it out any second. Come on Nice Me, you can do it!
Bridget: I don't think Olivia is behind this.
Buffy: Atta girl!
Day turns to night. Agent Handsome tells Guyliner that the woman at the dry cleaners is May Patel and her green card expired seven months prior. Guyliner thinks there's more to it than protecting illegals and asks for the deal on Osterman. Handsome says he's been suspected of extortion, racketeering and armed robbery. He's been indicted 16 times, but the last time he was convicted was for petty theft almost 20 years ago. Guyliner says it sounds like someone he knew back in Why-Oh-Why, Wyoming. Just then, he gets a phone call.