High School: Juliet keeps trying to flirt with Logan. His voice turns sharp and loud. "Juliet! You need to stop this." NNNBBFF watches, wide-eyed. Juliet: "Stop what?" Logan tells her she's being inappropriate and he won't tolerate her unacceptable behavior. Juliet: "If you think I'm flirting with you, stop flattering yourself. I'm just trying to be nice." She turns to NNNBBFF, "Andrea, let's get out of here." Great, now I have to rename NNNBBFF. Let's call her NNBBFF (Not Nameless Black Best Friend Forever) Logan: "Andrea, please wait in the hall. I'd like to finish my conversation with Miss Martin -- without the theatrics." Logan, did you take a bunch of stupid pills? A young girl comes onto you, and you send away your only witness. You've been so careful up 'til now. What are you thinking? Or possibly...what are you thinking with? NNBBFF murmurs an apology to Juliet on her way out. Juliet: "It's okay." Once NNBBFF leaves, Logan shuts the door behind her. Fool.
Why-Oh-Why, Wyoming, Night: Guyliner meets up with Officer Jimmy at the warehouse. Jimmy gives him a file on a cop he suspects is the Matador, but this is all a waste of our time, because Officer Jimmy is totally the Matador. I know it. You know it. Officer Jimmy certainly knows it. I just pray Agent Guyliner knows it, too.
Penn Station: 10:00 PM: All the New Yorkers in the audience jeer, because the set looks nothing like Penn Station. The Rest Of Us: "There, there, New Yorkers. It's a CW Soap." Bridget and Andrew look around, but they can't find John, anywhere. After a half hour has passed, Bridget decides Charlie isn't coming. It's then that he calls. "I told you to come alone." She apologizes and says Andrew wouldn't let her. John: "I'm not talking about London Fog..." Ahahahahaha. Were I not head over heels in love with Andrew, I would so be calling him London Fog from now on. John clarifies: "I'm talking about the cops." Bridget insists she didn't involve the police. He instructs her to look out the window. "Somebody did." There's magic afoot, because the very first window Bridget tries -- in all of Penn Station -- is the right one. She has Buffy's slayer sense. Bridget immediately spots the fuzz staking out the station. The New Yorkers in the audience remind us that Penn Station is crawling with cops, anyhow. The Rest Of Us: "There, there, New Yorkers. It's a CW Soap." Bridget wants another chance, but John says he can't give her one, with the cops following her. "Sorry, Siobhan. My good will's all maxed out." Was he really going to hand over Gemma? That seems...contrary to everything we've heard John say in this episode, especially when you consider his convo with Shiv.