Later, Faye shows up in her party dress at Lee's place. She is met by Eva who says that she's his girlfriend. Lee shows up and kisses Eva. She does not have good luck in that place. She stomps out and Lee tells Eva that she has a crush on him.

Diana is running the chips table at Casino Night when Grant throws down some crisp Benjamins. He decided to leave the next day. Ooh. She tells him that his Blackjack advice has an exception. I can't stand all the advice. He walks away and Melissa shows up carrying a tray of drinks, because that's completely legal. I guess they could non-alcoholic, but... still looks kinda bad.

Cassie's getting ready in her bathroom when Adam shows up and it doesn't scare her. Seriously? She tells Adam John's news about what happened on the boat. He gathers that Cassie is considering Ethan as the Judas of the old Circle. They argue about whose father is good or bad. He's a real baby about it. Later, she goes to Jake and tells him the news and he's upset that she's considering not telling John that she saw Ethan on the boat. Afterwards, he calls John.

Adam goes to Ethan. He wants to know what happened between him and Blackwell. He says it's affecting him and Cassie. Ethan says that she's worth fighting for. Spill it, Conant! Meanwhile, Faye is sulking around the fundraiser. Melissa says that Lee is an idiot. Oh wait, he's there. Faye tears into him, but Lee says it's complicated and kisses her. She's nice again.

John shows up at the fundraiser. Dawn is behind her in a quiet hallway and he throws her against a locker. She's a cat on a hot tin roof. She says she never believed he was dead. She says that she thinks they can get their power back. He wants to see Ethan and he has no time for her shit.

Adam decides to go the fundraiser and apologizes to Cassie, who is also cocktailing. They both agree to be easier on each other's dads. Dawn tells Cassie that her dad is there. Faye and Melissa use their powers to win at Blackjack. FINALLY. Some magic happens. Eva shows up at the fundraiser and is super upset. He tells her that he's with Eva now.

Jake ALSO shows up at the fundraiser. Can someone give this guy something to rub on? Melissa tells him that Cassie's really into Adam. Grant exchanges his winnings for two stuffed monkeys and gives one to Diana. Wow. Steamy. Cassie walks into the parking lot just in time to see John get stabbed by some shadowy person. She runs to his side, but then runs after the stabber. This is cool. The guy runs across the football field and Cassie runs after, turning the lights on with her power along the way. Then, she makes some bleachers break off and knock the guy down. She's pissed. She uses her power to pick up a piece of wood, then turns the guy over. It's Ethan. It doesn't matter, she's about to bash his brains in when John stops her. Ethan runs off. Later, John patches himself up and Cassie says that the dark magic was taking her to a bad place. John tells her that she has to stop practicing magic completely.