Ethan starts to feel woozy and goes to lie down, as Charlie is watching him. Outside, Cassie asks Jake if he ever murdered a witch. His face sort of says it all and she walks away. Lucy shows up with Dawn's, ostensibly to help find the crystals. Instead, she shanks the bitch right in her own foyer. As Dawn writhes on the floor, she tells her that she has always been working for the witch hunters and they're coming back to Chance Harbor. After tonight, the Circle won't have any power to protect them. Not that there aren't cobwebs growing on the Circle's powers anyway. Then, she leaves Dawn to bleed out.

As the party is winding down, Cassie is telling the Circle about activating the medallion. Diana's in because Cassie saw her father use it successfully. Adam is the last to agree. They meet in the woods behind Briar Hill, but first Cassie takes Adam aside and tells him that he was right about Jake. He replies that he accepts who she is, but doesn't think that she is defined by black magic. He's a feminist.

Charlie steals the crystal from a passed out Ethan. He doesn't cop a feel though. Gentleman. In the woods, Lucy instructs the Circle (including Jake) to hold hands around a fire. Meanwhile, Ethan's realizing that the crystal is gone. Lucy starts to run a spell. Melissa says that she doesn't feel well. Maybe too many drugs. Faye is swooning too. Cassie says that something is wrong. Melissa thinks it feels like that time Faye did the spell at the Fire/Ice dance, which took their powers away. Lucy has her Scooby-Doo moment. The medallion channels power in or out. It's working the out angle right now. Cassie says that she saw her father use the medallion to kill the witch hunters... and NOW she remembers what he said. She says some fancy witch words and fire shoots in a path from the central fire towards Lucy who has fallen and skitters backwards. Jake says she must be working with witch hunters. You think? She says that they threatened her. Cassie just wants to know if her father is alive. He is, but no one knows where he is. Cassie tells her to never come back to Chance Harbor and to tell the witch hunters that they're ready for them. Yeah! Before they leave, Jake tries to tell Cassie that she and he are similar, but she ain't having it.