Faye is at her house getting ready for the slumber party when Lee shows up at her door. He says that he's left a bunch of messages for him, but she reminds him that he didn't get her own power back for her. He argues that he did, but she and her Circle didn't like the way he did it. Touché. He has brought her something different. It looks like a cross between a dreamcatcher and a thing you'd use in lacrosse. A racket? Don't care. He tells her that it's a power totem that draws away weakness to intensify her strength. He invites her to dinner and she turns him down. He leaves the doll and says it and he are going to change her life. We can all agree that something's up with the doll, right?

Jake is at his house doing whatever it is he does while being a thing that fell to earth on the back of a golden calf floating on a cloud of butter and Sweetums when he sees that Isaac is there. Wha? He slams Isaac against the wall and is generally just really pissed because he saw that Eben killed his parents, not witchcraft. Isaac says that he only knows part of the story. Jake says that his parents were willing to give up witchcraft, but Isaac insists that Blackwell would have never let that happen. He says that John led the Circle to believe that the hunters were deceiving them? What? We saw Jake's father and mother agree to give up their powers, then they were killed. They didn't talk to John AT ALL in between those events. He says that John led them to slaughter, but this still doesn't make any sense. Isaac says that Jake can prevent the same thing from happening to his Circle if he gives the medallion to the witch hunters, but Jake is like, um, sure... let me get that for you. He tells Isaac to get out.

Cassie's back in the basement at 7 Briar Hill. She's just looking around, holding her medallion thinking about papa, when she turns around and sees the shrouded dude. Suddenly, Cassie is the most expressive she has ever been. She shrieks and runs up the stairs, where Adam is waiting for her. She tells him that someone is in the basement. They go downstairs and find nothing. She says that the man was wearing the same robe that her father was wearing when the witch hunters tried to kill her father. Adam asks why she was in the basement and she says she was trying to communicate with her father. Adam says that her father has had plenty of time to look for her. Good point.