Ava and Johnny fight over his past indiscretion. Johnny apologizes, and can't come up with an excuse. He points out that she was lucky that she didn't marry him because he was unreliable, but she already knew that. Ava says she didn't know he cheated on her. Ava realizes when it happened, during a vacation in Cabo, and that Johnny broke up with her a week later. She thinks he broke up with her because of Traci. Johnny asks if they can leave the past behind, but Ava runs out of the room.

Jay walks up and asks Bradin if he's seen Susannah. Bradin gives him attitude for ignoring Erica. Jay wonders why Bradin thinks he's going to let Erica down, and Bradin says it's due to "past history." As opposed to "future history" or "present history"? Instead of getting mad, or telling Bradin to mind his knitting, Jay says that it's a "point well taken," and goes to find Susannah.

Susannah is making out with Dalton in her bed. Jay bursts into the room and plays the role of angry boyfriend. Haven't these people heard of locks? Susannah tries to get Jay to get out and leave her alone. Jay threatens to fight Dalton, which gets Susannah to leave the room for a minute. Outside, Jay thinks that Susannah will thank him later, but she's not at all happy with him. Jay reminds Susannah what she said earlier, and then leaves Susannah to make her decision.

Goofy tells Nikki that she looks great. Nikki glances at Amber and her minions and invites Goofy up to her room. He accepts squeakily. Nikki makes sure that Amber and her minions are watching, and then leads Goofy off.

Traci rummages through the basket of keys, looking for her own. Doesn't it kind of defeat the purpose of collecting keys if the gatekeeper doesn't...you know, guard them? Ava walks up and asks how this all happened, because they were all friends. Traci thinks it was obvious that there was something between Bryant and Ava, but Ava denies it, and asks if Traci slept with Johnny for payback. Traci wishes she could say yes, but "the truth is, we were just stupid and young and hurt." Ava says that she never even thought about sleeping with Bryant. Traci doesn't seem to believe it, but Ava says that if Traci had asked, she would have been honest about it. Traci looks guilty and leaves.