Sam and Dean clomp into the lounge, loudly announcing their arrival instead of just sneaking in like they should have. "So, James didn't kill those --" Not surprisingly, Dean is cut off before he can finish asking his question. Spencer flings them across the room with a wave of his hand. James flings some lightning at Spencer, but it has little effect. Spencer magically lifts James off the ground. Just when the brothers are getting back on their feet, Spencer freezes them in place. "It's not only James's head I can get inside," he says. He treats the boys to various flashbacks. Sam remembers falling into the pit with Michael, his face catching on fire inside the cage. Dean remembers his mother dying, sees himself in Hell with the hooks tearing into his flesh. Some of these things they shouldn't be able to remember, but whatever. It's one of the few tolerable things about this episode.

While Spencer is distracted, Portia comes charging in on all fours and knocks him to the ground. She goes for his ridiculous tie. Spencer throws her across the floor, but she's bought the Winchesters enough time to ready their witch-killing brew. They light it and throw it at Spencer like a magical Molotov cocktail. Smoke swirls around him, tightens around his body until he explodes in red vapor. James rushes over to embrace Portia, who has resumed her human form. "Kids, don't try this at home," Dean says to nobody, for no reason.