Catholic Cadillac, which is actually a Catholic Station Wagon, but whatever, because there are less than seven minutes to go, and I want this episode over with already. Demonic Father Feely pulls up in front of The Lair Of Casey, and the gentlemen disembark with the demonic priest awkwardly adjusting himself. Oh, I'm kidding! I am kidding! Sam calls out his brother's name, and down in The Pit Of My Despair, Demonic Casey carefully and falsely smiles, "Looks like you win!" Topside, Sam decides he and Demonic Father Feely should split up to find an open entrance, and that is, of course, A Very Bad Move On Sam's Part, for Demonic Father Feely wastes not an instant before flipping his eyes beetle black and advancing upon an unsuspecting Sammy with malicious intent. So I skipped a little bit somewhere in there. Sue me. Fortunately for Sam, Bad-Ass Bobby's arrived from the badlands with the now-working Fucking Colt That Can Kill Anything Except When It Can't. Unfortunately for Bobby, Demonic Father Feely's got some wicked telekinetic mojo that the evil priest now unleashes upon poor Bobby's middle-aged ass, sending Bobby slamming heavily to the paved walk outside The Lair Of Casey. Sam attempts to retaliate with some holy water -- oh, Sam -- but finds himself crashing into the station wagon's windshield when Demonic Father Feely slaps him up with a little more telekinetic mojo. While the evil priest next deploys the telekinetic energy to invade The Lair, Darling Sammy scampers over to Bobby's side, gets the relevant information on The Fucking Colt's resurrected powers from his human mentor, receives a snitty bit of direction from Sparkly Haired Ruby, and finally chases after the priest.
Down in The Pit Of My Despair, Demonic Father Feely telekinetically knocks his way through several feet of Styrofoam, flings Dean against the far wall, shatters the Devil's Trap, and macks on Demonic Casey's lipstick for a bit before lifting Dean up into the air by his neck. Then, he foolishly toys with Dear El Deano just long enough for Sam to arrive with The Fucking Colt That Can Kill Anything Except When It Can't, Which Isn't Now, Actually, Because Darling Sammy Plugs Demonic Father Feely In The Chest, And The Priest Dies. And even as Dean shouts for him to stop, Sam plugs Demonic Casey in the chest, as well, and The Fucking Colt works on her, too. The blood from the demons' now-dead human hosts runs thickly across the floor into the METAL TEETH CHOMP!, which is happy enough to receive it, but growing increasingly worried that tonight will be Sam-free.