Matthew and Rob intersect at a guidepost, and Rob pats Matt's back, and -- debatably -- his ass as well. Peachy cautions them to be very quiet about what they're doing as we see Matthew embracing a pole and necklace, followed immediately by Jenna, who probably heard him successfully fumbling around behind her. The guideposts, by the way, are stationed immediately in front of the necklace stations. As Jenna claims a feathered necklace, she asks, "Does anybody see me takin' this one?" Peachy announces that she indeed has her second, and she gives two happy little thumbs up. Butch still has no necklaces, leading Peachy to announce that he needs some help. Jenna responds, "All those boys need help."
At an intersection in the course, Matthew tosses Butch some advice, and Peachy marvels that they're actually working together in an individual challenge. Jenna agrees that it's not fair as Peachy rubs it in: "They're teamin' up on you, Jenna." She responds that they'll have to fight her "to the death" for it. Butch finally reaches a guidepost, while we see Matthew in the background ramming himself up against a wall. Peachy points out that although they may be working each other, they're not helping each other very much. We see mud-covered, trudging feet, as Peachy narrates, "Rob...wandering...aimlessly." Hee. Butch and Jenna cross paths again, and Peachy orders them to say hello. They do.
By this point, the S4 are all hovering around the same guideposts, probably just trying to follow one of the others to a necklace, which Jenna successfully does after overhearing Matt again. So Matthew and Jenna are tied with three necklaces each; Rob follows with two; and Butch has finally gotten one. Jenna and Matthew both race for their final necklaces, but Matthew is stalled at a guidepost before moving on his way as Peachy announces, "Matthew, movin' fast...he's smellin' something!" Dramatic music flares as Jenna surprises herself by stumbling upon the center post. While the men look tired and dismayed, Jenna insists that Peachy doesn't know how badly she needed the win. Matt finally stops fumbling at a guidepost and walks away, still wearing his blindfold. Hee.
Peachy congratulates Jenna on her "nice work," and concludes from her win that anything can happen. She's safe from the vote, while the others are "fair game." He'll see them at tonight's Tribal Council.
A reflection of the Jackée flag takes us to the real Jackée flag on Day 37. The S4 stomp back to camp, led by an invigorated Jenna, who marvels that it's always a surprise to find the camp in one piece. Rob interviews that he, Matthew, and Butch had a plan, and that Jenna's winning immunity threw everything into chaos. Matt laments, "Um, I couldn't, my problem was -- I was tryin' to find earth." Hee. He's still trying to find earth, as far as I'm concerned. Rob tells us that he bit off all his fingernails and doesn't know what to do, because it's a very scary time in the game for him. We then see Matthew and Rob begging to launder Jenna's stinky socks for her. She declines before telling us in an interview that she really needed immunity, it felt great, and now the others will have to change their plans.