Tarzan specifically asks Bill what he wants to do and Bill laughs, but interviews that if he can take advantage of the groundswell against Leif, it might be to his advantage. Yeah, but what if they're not planning to vote out Leif? Did Bill even think of that? Jay says that he's "bum-puzzled" right now. You and me both, Jay. Sabrina tells the women that something like this would never happen on their tribe, and Monica says that she doesn't want to go to Tribal and vote someone out.
So what happened? We see a line of people holding torches approaching camp, and sure enough, the men walk in. Probst has a look on his face like, "THE FUCK?" and then "AWESOME!" and then "Holy shit." Once the men are seated, Probst says that in all of the seasons, a tribe has never arrived at Tribal Council after winning immunity. Probst asks Troy what happened, and he says that everyone got together and agreed to give up immunity to vote Bill out. But then Leif told Bill they were voting him out, and that broke trust. Um, that's not at all the order of operations. Leif told Bill they were going to vote him out LAST TIME, and then they decided to give up immunity. That's a nice story that Troy is telling though.
Probst clarifies that Leif gave up secrets from his alliance. Leif says that he plays with his heart, and he's been getting closer to Bill on a friend level. Leif also says that Bill asked and Leif told him, which also isn't how it went down. There's a whole lot of retcon going on here. Either that, or we aren't being shown large chunks of the events as they happened. I'm still going with the theory that this is all an elaborate ruse to get Bill to agree to go to Tribal. Probst asks Jay why it's so urgent to get rid of Leif. Jay admits that he didn't see the point at first, but he felt he had to go along with the tribe or put a target on his own back. Yes, but Bill could have said no. He already has a target on his back! I am bum-puzzled by Bill's actions.