Butch says, "These old bones just aren't what they used to be," and Rob agrees that his "chicken legs" are struggling. Peachy, perched on the boat, reminds them that if they fall or jump off, they should make a quick swim to the fishing boat, because they know what's in the water. Roger starts thrashing around again, and Peachy points out that he's struggling as the camera pans over to reveal a smiling Deena and Jenna.

Alex yells that the challenge wouldn't be so bad if it wasn't so hot outside, as we see Butch wipe his sweaty brow. In case we didn't get that it's hot, a shot of the bright hot sun follows. A defeated-sounded Roger announces that he won't be able to stand much longer, and Peachy snits, "That's confidence. I'll give you that!" He adds that there will be "temptations" ahead, but that if Roger wants to forego those by dropping out now, that's his prerogative.

Roger hangs on, but only because Jenna out of the blue announces that she'll take off her clothes for chocolate and peanut butter, causing Rob to yell, "Get. The girl. Some chocolate. And peanut butter, Probst!" HeiDDi volunteers to join Jenna, and so Peachy produces a plate bearing a big squirt of peanut butter, Oreos, and two glasses of Coke. Jenna confirms that they are indeed going for it, and HeiDDi's already got her shirt half off. Meanwhile, Butch looks at his feet moaning, "Oh, God. Why? I'm not lookin'. I gotta stay focused." Both women are now down to their pixilated upper bits, but HeiDDi seems more concerned with where she can keep her clothes than with the fact that she's naked on a national television show. Jenna, meanwhile, orders HeiDDi just to pull her pants down to her ankles, causing Alex to yell, "Yeah! That's what I'm talking about!" In the background, Butch continues to chant, "I'm not looking,'" adding, "All the kids at school, I'm not lookin'!" Jenna pulls her shorts to her knees, but HeiDDi takes Jenna's earlier command literally and struggles to get her shorts all the way down to her ankles. Peachy complains that the girls aren't even trying to tempt the men, and Dave Rockett insists, "I am lookin'!" Jeena calmly asks if HeiDDi wants to get in the water now, but HeiDDi is still engaged in successfully lowering her shorts. Finally, they both manage to get off their perches and swim toward shore, Jenna looking collected, while HeiDDi looks straggly and confused. She's wondering if she'll be able to get her Deb Shop shorts and top back. Peachy announces that it's only thirty minutes into the game, and that it will take a while for another deal to be offered, but that he still thinks the women earned their reward. The men applaud, apparently because the women successfully managed to remove their clothes. Dave adds, "Well done!"