After four hours, Peachy brings something out, which they deduce is peanut butter and apples. Elisabeth says, "It is not peanut butter and apples you guys. Shut up." Peachy then tells them it's not peanut butter and apples: it's peanut butter and apples and chocolates. Elisabeth asks if it's Skippy. I would have asked if it was chunky or smooth. Peachy is smirking -- he likes rubbing things, like peanut butter, in people's faces. Jeff asks who's getting the food and Elisabeth yells Colby's name for some reason. I guess she didn't want Nick to have any? Peachy then calls Colby and Nick over to partake and Elisabeth jokingly slaps herself and says, "This is why you keep your mouth shut. My mom says, 'Elizabeth keep you mouth shut!' Do I listen? No!" And it's really cute. Obviously. Since it's Elisabeth, after all. And she's cute. That Elisabeth. So perky and cute. Do you think we're supposed to think Elisabeth is cute? Because I'm not getting it. Peachy then says, "That's pure peanut butter right there," and I'm so glad to know it's not impure or anything. Because who wants peanut butter that's having dirty thoughts? Peachy then announces that anyone who bails can join him, and Rodger's in the water. He says he was just waiting for those words. Peachy tries to encourage the others to jump so he can get over to the crew happy hour but they say it's not enough. Peachy says "It's plenty for Rodger," and then the camera pans over to Rodger with peanut butter all over his face and teeth. He grins and says, "It ain't very good. Stick it out." Colby says the peanut butter was better than any of the wine and cheese. The Ogakor appear to be targeting Jeff with their attempts at persuasion, and I have no idea why he can't see it. Lamber baaahs something or other. Colby finally says that Jeff should "Come on over to the dark side," and how can Jeff refuse an invitation to the dark side from Colby? Jerri is covering her face with her hands and I'm not sure if it's because she doesn't want to watch them eating peanut butter, or if it's to hide the fact that she knows they may have just secured Ogakor's future. Jeff is very lucky he didn't choke on the huge slab of peanut butter he stuffs in his mouth.
Peachy realizes he can talk no one else into jumping perch and returns to land. But then he's back again a couple of hours later with ice cream cones, doing a pitiful push-up onto a pedestal floating in the center of the perches. Tina says with a big grin on her face, "What you got there, buddy?" but "buddy" takes about five minutes for her to say. And I think Tina's a total hard-ass. She doesn't seem to be affected at all. It's now six hours and forty-seven minutes. Jerri is squatting on her perch -- is that allowed? Peachy says he has ice cream and "really hot chocolate" and Jerri happily jumps in followed immediately by little Lamber. Lamber says she couldn't stay up there any longer, but we know she means she couldn't stay up there any longer without Jerri. I hate Jerri but I think at this point, I'd rather see her win than Lamber. Please put the words "Hate mail" in the subject line of your emails so I know immediately to delete them. We then see a shot of Lamber's chocolate-covered hands as she licks the chocolate from the V between her first and second fingers in a very lewd and suggestive gesture meant for Elisabeth.